Submerged

  • Plymouth And Devon Shipwrecks
  • World Shipwrecks
  • Special Reports
  • Recommended Reading

Minnihaha

On the 10 January I814the 645 ton wooden sailing ship Minnehaha had reached Falmouth with a cargo of Guano after a long voyage from Callao in Peru. On the following day she set off Ï…r Dublin, where she was due to discharge her cargo. Shortly after she left Falmouth the weather deteriorated and a severe north westerly gale started to blow. By the afternoon of Sunday 18 January Captain Jones thought he saw the light from the Wolf Rock lighthouse and ordered the helm to be put down. Shortly afterwards, the channel pilot, a Captain Yolk countermanded this order with out telling the Captain and almost immediately the Minnehaha rushed full tilt into the Jolly Rocks near the south east corner of Peninnis Head, ramming into the rocks with all sails set.

The Minnihaha aground.

The Minnihaha aground.

A huge hole was smashed into her port bow and within minutes she was underwater. Those who had not been swept straight away and drowned clambered into the rigging for safety. Captain Jones became quite unhinged, and undressing in the rigging he threw himself into the water shouting ‘with Gods help I will save your lives’. He was never seen alive again. Mr. Thomas the first mate, took a more practical aproach,and when dawn broke he led the remaining nine survivors down over the rigging, along the forestays and over the jib boom to safety on the rocks. The Minnehaha which was uninsured, soon became a complete loss, and pounded to pieces on the steep rocks around Peninnis head.

Dive report

This wreck now lies in roughly two places. The main body of the wreck lies right at the bottom of the Jolly Rocks in about 90 to 100 feet of water. Because of a previous dive we could not get down to this, so we had to content ourselves with the bits that were in about 50 feet. The bottom here is composed of huge boulders rising up the sheer face of the rocks. It was very rough on the day we dived and the surface water was very turbulent. One minute you were in 50 feet and the next you were being bounced around on top of the boulders in less than twenty feet. Although there is not a lot of wreckage to be seen, it is plain that a wreck is here. A few boom crutches and some anchor chain litter the bottom together with other pieces of broken metal. In amongst the boulders I found a wooden sheeve from a deadeye block, but with the poor vis, less than 15 feet and very mucky, it was difficult to have a good look. However there is obviously quite a lot to see, and with better conditions this site would be well worth another visit.

One Foggy Day in May:Lady Charlotte and Italia.

1917 had not been a good year for England. The Great War was well into it’s third year, and the carnage on the battlefields of France was at it’s highest. At sea, ships were being torpedoed and sunk in ever increasing numbers, yet still the cargo steamers plied their trade. Even the war could not disguise the fact that the sea itself was still their greatest enemy. Storms, however ferocious can often be weathered, but fog, especially around some-where as treacherous as the Scilly Isles often leaves a skipper with nothing better to do than pray.

Unfortunately prayers are not always answered, and it was on one such foggy day on 11 May 1917 that two cargo steamers, the, Lady Charlotte and the Italia, both became total wrecks within hours of each other on the rocky coasts of the Scillies. The Lady Charlotte formerly called the Aphrodite, was a steamer of some 3593 tons and had been built by the Tyne Iron Steamboat Company in 1905. On the afternoon of 11 May, the Lady Charlotte, outward bound from Cardiff to France carrying a cargo of coal, encountered dense fog. After becoming hopelessly lost she finally ran aground at Porth Hellick Point. Fortunately, the sea was fairly calm and all the crew managed to escape before the vessel sank and became a total loss.

The Lady Charlotte.

The Lady Charlotte.

A few hours later, at about half past three in the afternoon whilst all the commotion and excitement of the Lady Charlotte’s wrecking was enthralling the locals, the steamer Italia smashed onto the Wingletang Rock less than four miles to the west of Porth Hellic Point. Like the Lady Charlotte, the Italia was carrying a cargo of coal on a voyage from Cardiff to Taranto when she too encountered dense fog. The Italia was a vessel of 2792 tons and had been built by Hawthorn Leslie and Company of Newcastle. She was rigged as a two masted schooner, and besides her cargo she carried six passengers and sixty-three crew, a very large number for such a small ship.

Dick Larn back in the sixties with a cannon from the Gilstone wreck site. Photo R.Larn.

Dick Larn back in the sixties with a cannon from the Gilstone wreck site. Photo R.Larn.

When at long last the crew of the 1talia finally reached the main island of St Mary’s, the Scillonians assumed that they were the victims of a torpedo attack further offshore. Since none of the crew spoke any English, they could not tell the islanders about the loss of their ship, and soon the whole incident just became a memory. The 1talia lay undisturbed until 1964 when Richard Larn, a prominent wreck historian located and subsequently purchased her. Still not completely sure of her identification, he sifted very carefully through the wreckage until he found the ships patent log. Being a very through man, Larn cleaned up the log, which revealed a serial number. When checked against the builder’s records, the serial number positively identified the wreck as the Italia, and put paid to a forty seven year old mystery.

This photo of the 'Italia's' sister ship is a near as I can get.

This photo of the ‘Italia’s’ sister ship is a near as I can get.

All though both vessels sunk under similar circumstances, their wreck sites are completely different, and are both well worth a visit. Today the Lady Charlotte rests close inshore, about midway between Porth Hellick. Point and Newfoundland Rocks. Although most people dive her from a boat, it is possible to get at the wreck from the shore. The remains of the Lady Charlotte now lie on a rocky bottom covered with fairly thick kelp. She is well broken up, and her depth ranges from about 30 feet to 110 feet. The main mass of the wreck however, is in the 50 to 70 feet range, so this allows plenty of time to have a good look around. From 3O feet, where there are small pieces of wreckage and iron girders, the bottom slopes gently down, leading you to larger and larger pieces of wreckage which are scattered amongst the rocks. Soon you come to a great jumble of steel plates and girders, which are scattered over a very wide area. Towering above all this twisted metal, are the Lady Charlotte’s two huge boilers. These make a very impressive site, and their memory lingers on long after the dive is over. Although not as impressive as the Plymton – Hathor , this wreck site has a lot to offer visually, and is a very good wreck for those who just want to take it easy and have a jolly good poke around.

Although I dived and wrote about this wreck in the 1980’s, this video was shot by peter Rowlands in 2013.

Four miles to the west of Porth Hellick Point lay the Wingletang Rock and the wreck site of the 1talia. Stuck down one side of a reef, most of the 1talia now lies well broken up in over 120 feet of water. The very rocky bottom is completely strewn with wreckage, and if you swim over to the other side of’ the reef there is still more of the wreck to be seen lying in very large and deep gullies. Most of the wreckage starts at about 85 feet, but very quickly the depth drops to well over 120 feet, and it is very easy to get carried away and forget all about your original dive plan. There is an awful lot of wreckage to explore, and the bottom is extremely rugged with huge rocks and gullies all filled with interesting pieces of wreckage. The most fascinating part of the wreck is the iron propeller. This is still fixed to the shaft. complete with a smashed up ‘A’ bracket. All this lies on top of the other wreckage, and it is quite an experience to swim all along the shaft to the Italia’s propeller. Whilst the Italia is very exciting to dive on, the Lady Charlotte is visually much more pleasing. So in a way the two wrecks complement each other in a way they never did while on the surface. Like every thing left in the sea, these wrecks are slowly being pounded to pieces. So if you get the chance to dive on them, take it with both hands you wont be disappointed.

H.M.S. Blazer

The Blazer was an old steam tug of 283 tons. She had been built by S.M. Knight of Ayr in 1888. She was formerly called the Charm and operated out of Liverpool. She sank on the 10 November 1918 close inshore near the Conger ledgers.

Dive Report

The wreckage of the Blazer now rests in about 30 feet of water on a reasonably flat bottom consisting of rock and fairly thick kelp. We hadn’t quite hooked into the main body of the wreck, but after a bit of searching we eventually found it.

The Blazer, although not whole, is still in large recognizable pieces. The bows are virtually intact, and not far away lies the stern section, also quite well preserved. The boiler lies almost in the middle of the two sections, but slightly to one side. There is a mass of plating and other bits and pieces which provide a lot of scope for general rummaging around. But the main attraction is the intactness of this wreck. The conditions were very bad on our dive, strong currents and quite rough seas. So in calmer weather the Blazer should be even better. The fish life was a bit sparse, except for the wrasse which were there in quite respectable numbers and variations.

Worth another visit.

V83 Destroyer

The V83 belonged to the V67 class of destroyers (told you it was confusing). She was 269 ft long, 27 ft in the beam, had a top speed of 34 knots and a complement of 85 officers and men. The V83 was launched on 10th June 1916 and scuttled with the rest of the fleet on June 21 1919. However she was beached before she completely sunk, and was finally broken up in 1928. Her armament includes three 3.45 in guns six anti aircraft guns and she also carried 24 mines.

This is the V67, a dead ringer for V83.

This is the V67, a dead ringer for V83.

I dived this wreck in 1985 and this is what I wrote in my notes.

Vis 25ft. depth 50 ft to 6 ft. the wreck has its stern intact, with rudder still affixed. On top of the stern is a gun with brass all over it, and that is just the start. This wreck is very smashed up and points uphill towards the shore. It lays on a sandy bottom, but as it goes closer to the shore the kelp starts to take over. However all around lays the wreck with masses of brass and lead. Brass fittings are everywhere and most are very difficult to remove, but that didn’t really matter as there were lots just lying around waiting to be picked up. Halfway along you come up against another gun. Fantastic. After that its just wreckage. Boilers, brass, davits, brass, lead, copper heat exchangers, wreckage, wreckage wreckage. This is a great wreck for mooching about on. There is so much to see and poke at, and if you get bored you can go back and have a look at the guns. The other bits of the wreck are quite large and provide lots of holes and overhangs to crawl around in. I really liked this one.

UB.116

Halfway through 1918 it was obvious to all that Germany had lost the War, and its Navy in particular, was almost fatally crippled with low morale and disaffection. An earlier attempt to confront the British Grand Fleet and bring them to battle had been frustrated, not by the Royal Navy, but by the German sailors themselves who mutinied and ran up the Red Flag. The U-boat arm however was largely unaffected in spite of its huge losses, and so in a last attempt to restore some pride to the German navy, an operation was conceived to place a lone submarine inside Scapa Flow the home of the Royal navy’s grand Fleet.

This is UB40 seen in 1916 and is the same class as UB116.

This is UB40 seen in 1916 and is the same class as UB116.

Its mission was to penetrate the Flows complex defences and sink as many ships as possible, regardless of any risks involved to the crew or the submarine. The idea was to put out of commission as many ships as possible before another planned outing of the German High Sea’s Fleet for a final Great Battle. The thinking of the High Command was, that even if Germany did not win this battle, the act of defiance would somehow burnish an almost otherwise fatally tarnished reputation and give them some much needed bargaining power when the German Nation had to finally admit defeat.

Unfortunately German Intelligence wasn’t very good at this point in the War, and they failed to realise that the Grand Fleet had largely been dispersed to other ports. Even if the plot succeeded in placing the sub inside the Flow there would be precious few ships to sink. On 25th October 1918, UB116, a 519 ton submarine armed with eleven torpedo’s left Heligoland for Scapa Flow. On board were four officers and thirty three ratings under the command of Lt. J.J.Emsmann. The Captain had been extensively briefed by the U-boat Staff who had advised him to penetrate the Flow through Hoxa Sound. This was because other U-boats passing through the Pentland Firth had reported that this entrance was in regular use by the Royal Navy and so was unlikely to be blocked by nets, mines or other obstructions.

The briefing was catastrophically wrong. Hoxa Sound was mined, the mines being controlled from the shore where they could be detonated electrically. Even worse, there were detector loops positioned on the seabed, which became active when an electric current was generated by the magnetic field of any vessel crossing them. Finally there were Hydrophones to pick up any engine noises of an approaching ship or submarine. On 28th October at 8.21 in the evening, the Hydrophones on Stanger Head, Flotta, picked up the first sounds of UB116’s engines. No friendly ships were expected, so the detector loops were switched on and everybody sat down to await developments.

Meanwhile Lt. Emsmann seemed to have convinced himself that all would be well if he just kept out of sight underwater. He was almost right. It wasn’t until 11.30 in the evening that he was finally sighted by a lookout when he came to periscope depth to confirm his position. To his delight he found that he was right where he wanted to be, inside the defences and near the Boom entrance. As he conned his submarine slowly towards the Boom entrance its magnetic field activated the mines, and on shore somebody pressed the detonate button. The UB116 was rent asunder killing all the crew instantly, and what was left swiftly sunk to the bottom leaving just a patch of oil on the surface at the mouth of Pan Hope.

A month later the War was over, and so UB116 was the last U-boat to be sunk in W.W.1, and incidentally the first to be sunk by a shore controlled minefield.

This was the first wreck I ever dived on at Scapa in1985, and these were the impression I wrote down.

This wreck lay in 95 ft with viz 25ft. The wreck is very broken up and scattered but our skipper put us on the main part where we could see the compressed air bottles. And part of the hull containing the engine area. Lots of lead and pipe around and some very nice brass worming gear. Right at the start I saw a conger eel poking out of off a steel pipe and then further along another quite large one with its head sticking out of a hole in the wreckage. I was only saying to the lads that I hardly ever see congers. There is a lot of brass lying around especially a thick brass pipe with a nice cap on it. To well fixed to get it off. The bottom consisted of sand, and lying around were various pieces of gear including a deck winch with the drum buried in the sand. Steel frames stuck out of the sand poking up into the water and the whole wreck was very picturesque. Its not a great wreck, but it’s a bloody good start.

Thames

It was August 1914 before the Admiralty at last approved the defences for Scapa Flow. St Margaret’s Hope became a subsidiary base, which employed as many as two thousand men to do the work. The first submarine obstructions were little more than buoys moored across the Channels with herring nets strung between them. In November more robust steel nets and block ships were sunk across the eastern channels. These old merchant ships were brought up to the Flow without any ballast, and so were extremely light. It was very difficult to sink them in the right positions as the tides could run up to nine knots through Holm Sound. Eventually they were all successfully sunk correctly, and soon became part of the scenery until the more effective Churchill Barriers, with roads running across the top were built in the Second World War.

Block ships in Holm Sound. The Thames is on the right.

Block ships in Holm Sound. The Thames is on the right.

The block ships were particularly conspicuous in Holm Sound, especially the elegant shape of the former Royal Mail Steam Packet Company steamer Thames. She had once been commanded by Admiral Jellicoe’s father, and was a graceful three masted two funnel steamer, with a clipper bowsprit. When she was sunk, by the simple expedient of blowing her bottom out, she settled up right, and still gave the impression that she was still sailing on into Lamb Holm. Lying either side of her, to complete the blockage of the channel, were three other ships. The Numidian was a former Alland Line Trans Atlantic passenger ship, the Arangi came from the New Zealand line, and completely submerged was the Minieh.

Churchill Barrier under construction.

Churchill Barrier under construction.

After the First war the local fishermen kicked up about the inconvenience of not being able to use the Eastern Channels, and after a bit of argy bargy, the Admiralty said it would do something but then procrastinated and stonewalled for years, saying it was all too difficult. This was rightly seen as complete humbug buy the locals, as only a few miles away from these block ships, one of the greatest salvage operations in history was being carried out with salvaged German Battleships and Cruisers popping up all over the place. Eventually in 1929 the Admiralty gave the go ahead to remove the Thames and some other block ships, and so clear the navigable channel of Kirk Sound. They then handed over ownership of all the block ships to the County Council, and they in turn handed over the removal operation of the Thames to James Mitchell and Son of Dundee, on a no cure no pay basis. Bad move.

Scapa Flow Defences WW2.

Scapa Flow Defences WW2.

The Company was very confident, and work began in the summer of 1930 plugging all the holes in the hull. Unfortunately by the time the winter weather stopped proceedings, the Thames still wasn’t ready to lift. Work resumed in May 1931, but in July the Company announced that it would be abandoning the work. After nearly two years of toil it was considered impossible to re float the Thames, as her hull was ‘as thin as sixpence’. So there she stayed, gently rotting away, when suddenly she was back in the spotlight as one dark night in Gunter Prien in U47 committed one of the most daring raids of the U-boat war by creeping into Scapa Flow and torpedoing the Royal Oak with catastrophic results.

Anti submarine boom.

Anti submarine boom.

It turned out that the channel he came in by, which was supposed to be impassable to submarines, was in fact perfectly navigable, and that the Admiralty knew about it as long ago as 26 may 1939, nearly four months before War broke out. Once more the Admiralty wanted to save money, so they ignored the report sent in by the survey vessel H.M.S.Scott, which noted that the supposed blocked channel was in fact 400 ft wide, with a depth of over two fathoms at low tide. The ‘experts’ at the Admiralty considered a determined attack on the Flow as ‘unlikely’. After sinking the Royal Oak, Prien successfully negotiated the channel on the south side of Kirk Sound, passing close to the uninhabited island of Lamb Holm, almost scraping the barnacles of the Thames as he slid past to safety. In his log, Prien recorded the Thames’ two masts and funnels as a ‘schooner’.

That will do nicely.

That will do nicely.

At the end of the War steel was in short supply, so the thousands of tons lying in the shallows looked to be a useful resource. One by one all the block ships, including the Thames were stripped of any useful metal and steel plate, and their remains left to rust where they lay, and most are still there today.

I dived this wreck in 1985, and this is what I wrote in my notes.

Viz 15 ft at a depth of 50 ft. very silty. so a careless fin stirs it all up The Thames wreckage is jumbled up with what is left of the others, and seems to be lying on its side. Along one side is a whole row of portholes and as I drifted in through a hole in the hull, there almost covered by the mud was a loose porthole. Lots of other twisted plate and bits and pieces, but a porthole will do nicely.The rest of the wreckage is almost impossible to orientate on as its just a jumble of metal tossed by the scrappers into the shallows. if you dont stir it up though its very entertaining.

Overview: Scapa Flow – The German Valhalla

If you go just about as far north as you can go by car, and then take a two hour ferry ride, you will end up in the Orkney Islands. Beautiful and rugged, the islands cover an area of some 1200 square miles of wild ocean, encompassing some seventy tiny islands. The Ocandians make a living much as they always have, fishing the wild seas and farming the bare windswept land. Apart from its awesome beauty, (when the sun sets on a clear evening, you wonder if it is the start of the second coming) Orkney has little to commend it apart from the friendliness of its people and a particularly good malt whisky.

The German Fleet at Scapa Flow.

The German Fleet at Scapa Flow.

However there is one thing that makes these islands unique, and that is Scapa Flow, just about the best natural anchorage anywhere in the world. Hated by generations of sailors for its desolate location and mind numbing boredom, Scapa Flow, in its time, has housed some of the biggest battle fleets ever to be assembled anywhere on earth. It was from here that the British Fleet under Admiral Jellicoe sailed out to do battle at Jutland, and it was here that the horrendous tragedy of the Royal Oak took place, leaving eight hundred dead. Even so, all this would no doubt have passed forgotten into history if not for one of the most bizarre events in Naval history, the self destruction of the entire German High Seas Fleet. How could this have happened?

Today with our reliance on nuclear arms, and the consequent rundown of our conventional forces, it is almost impossible for most of us to imagine the sheer might of the Battle Fleets at the turn of the century. Today we consider the aircraft carrier Invincible to be a huge ship, but compared with something like the German Battleship Konig, she does not seem quite so impressive. Even her armament does not really compare for all its twentieth century sophistication. The Konig for instance had ten twelve inch guns in five twin turrets all on the centre line. This meant that they could all fire broadside. Each shell weighed over nine hundred pounds, so when the Konig roared, over nine thousand pounds of armour piecing high explosive hurtled through the air at over 2400 feet per second. Only God could help if you were on the receiving end.

Boarding party.

Boarding party.

In their day the British and German Battle Fleets represented the ultimate in high technology, and were I suppose their equivalent of today’s nuclear arms race. Vast amounts were spent by both sides to build bigger and more powerful ships, and in this manner the seeds were sown that finally brought forth the terrible harvest of destruction in the Great War.

The German Navy under Tirpitz were convinced that if their fleet was powerful enough, Britain would accede to their ambitions in Europe rather than concede control of the high seas. Nothing could have been further from the truth. Britain with its huge Empire depended on the Navy, and over the years had kept a relatively small standing Army, relying on it’s awesome sea power to quash any stirrings abroad. The emergence of a powerful German Navy on its doorstep had a destabilizing effect and was bound to provoke mistrust between the two ‘super powers’. Soon the balance of power in Europe became irrevocably unbalanced. War was inevitable, and each countries Navy was determined not to be found wanting.

The Derflinger sinking.

The Derflinger sinking.

 

In the event the War at Sea was inconclusive. The two huge Battle Fleets met only once, at Jutland, and the outcome of that battle has been argued over ever since. Both sides claimed victory, and although the German Fleet sunk more ships and killed more sailors they failed to seize control of the North Sea. For the rest of the war they never again challenged the British Fleet to a full action, so strategically the Germans lost, and with their defeat went their best chances of winning the war.

On the 5 October 1918 with its Armies in mutiny on the Western Front, and the Navy barricaded by the British, the German Government offered an Armistice, and by the beginning of November hostilities ceased. The German High Seas Fleet based at Wilhelmhaven was due for dispersal to neutral ports to await the outcome of the peace talks. It soon became clear however, that the logistics of interning seventy four ships in different neutral ports would be virtually impossible, so the British insisted that the entire fleet should be interned at Scapa Flow. This was hardly a neutral port, and totally against the spirit of the agreement drawn up under the Armistice. The German Naval officers were not unnaturally furious. To them neutral internment meant that technically they were still in command of their ships pending the outcome of the peace talks. But internment by the British meant virtual surrender. They felt the dishonour very keenly. Here was arguably the worlds most powerful Battle Fleet, unbeaten in combat, finally being defeated by the betrayal of its own politicians.

 

The battleship Baden being salvaged.

The battleship Baden being salvaged.

Meanwhile in Germany revolution was sweeping the country, and on board the High Seas Fleet morale, already at rock bottom, broke down into widespread mutiny, and the formation of so called ‘Soldiers Councils’. Officers found it almost impossible to keep any discipline, and it was only the faint hope that the Battle Fleet would be allowed home after the peace talks that held the Navy together. The man chosen to lead the mighty German Fleet into internment was Rear Admiral Ludwick von Reuter. At best it was a degrading job for any officer to take on, but Reuter, at the personal request of Admiral Hipper was determined to do it and somehow preserve the honour of the German Navy into the bargain.

On the 19 November 1918 Reuter led the High Seas Fleet out from Wilhelmshaven on their last journey, a rendezvous with the British Fleet at the Firth of Forth. Here, five Battlecruisers, eleven Battleships, eight Lightcruisers and six flotilla’s of fifty Torpedoboat-Destroyers were to be inspected to make sure they had completely disarmed in accordance with the terms of the Armistice. When satisfied the British Navy would lead this once proud German High Seas Fleet in groups to their final anchorage, Scapa Flow. As Reuter sadly wrote years later, ‘we were disarmed and dishonoured’.

 

Sailors from the S.S. Nurenburg surrendering to the British.

Sailors from the S.S. Nurenburg surrendering to the British.

Reuter saw internment under the British as virtual surrender. With their love of legal niceties, the German Navy still saw the peace talks as a vehicle for their own salvation on equal terms, almost as if the war had not been lost but somehow brought to a draw. The British however considered the Germans to be the vanquished and treated them accordingly. In 1918 there was not much evidence of the British sense of fair play around Scapa Flow.

Scuttling was on everybody’s minds. For Reuter it seemed the only way of denying his ships to the Enemy if the peace talks went badly. The British had already circulated orders aimed at minimising the effects of scuttling, but knew in their heart of hearts that they could do little about it. (In the event all but twenty two of the ships completely sank, the rest were beached). Seven months were to go by until the Armistice came to an end, If the peace talks had not succeeded a state of war would once again break out. If this happened, Rear Admiral Reuter had decided that he would sink his entire fleet of seventy four ships rather than let the British have them.

Unfortunately for Reuter, the only information that he could get about the peace talks was what he was told by the British, or what he could read in four day old copies of the Times. This lack of up to date information had a bizarre consequence. By now it was almost certain that Reuter knew that his fleet would never get back to Germany, and therefore he would almost certainly have scuttled it, if only to preserve his notion of the German Navy’s honour. However it must be said that his actual decision to scuttle was based on a misleading report in a copy of the Times that was four days old.

At Versailles the peace talks were in chaos, and as the final date drew near, a close agreement still had not been reached. In the end the British, tired of the whole squalid mess, gave the German Government an ultimatum to either accept the peace terms by noon on the 21 June or face renewed hostilities. That is what Reuter read in his copy of the Times, and that is the information that he acted on. What he did not know is that later on the same day the Germans capitulated, accepted the terms, and the Armistice was extended by two days to tie up the loose ends.

Rear Admiral Ludwick von Reuter, Commander of the German High Seas Fleet.

Rear Admiral Ludwick von Reuter, Commander of the German High Seas Fleet.

So when the 21 June 1919 dawned, there was Rear Admiral Ludwig von Reuter dressed in his best uniform pacing the deck of his flagship the Emden. At ten thirty he ordered the prearranged coded signal to be hoisted, Paragraph Eleven – Confirm. The controlled suicide of an entire fleet had begun. With their customary good timing the British had chosen this day of all days to withdraw the escorting Battleships and their attendant destroyers from Scapa Flow to send them on exercise. The only witnesses were a bunch of school children on a boat trip to view the ‘defeated Hun’. In a recent television programme some of those children, now grown old relived their memories. The passage of time had done nothing to diminish the clarity and vividness of their recollections. For them it had been the most incredible experience of their lives, and they could never forget it. If you are lucky enough to dive on the remains of this once mighty fleet, I can assure you that you too will always remember it. It is truly the German Valhalla.


Special Report: Scapa Flow:

  • Overview: Scapa Flow – the German Valhalla
  • Brummer
  • Geleitboot F2
  • Koln
  • Konig

Konig

Like a huge sea monster, the vast iron hull of the German battleship Konig suddenly appeared out of the gloom as we swam down the shot rope towards her. I knew that the Konig was going to be a large wreck, but even so I as completely unprepared for the sheer enormity of this vessel and for the way it seems to project its personality, lying there on its side like some stricken dinosaur from another age.

The battleship Konig.

The battleship Konig.

In its day however, the Konig was far from being a dinosaur and was in fact just about the last word in German naval technology. In the Imperial German Navy created by Grand Admiral Tirpitz in the early 1900’s, Germany had finally found a suitable symbol of her new and growing power. The navy was determined to build a fleet large enough to frighten off the British and the Konig represented the penultimate of the first generation German dreadnought battleships.

Built in the 1911 construction programme at Wilhelmshaven, the Konig was the ‘name’ ship of her class which included the Markgraff and the Derflingger. Displacing a massive 25,000 tons, the Konig was 573 feet on the waterline and nearly 97 feet wide. In places her armour plating was 14 inches thick and she had the ability to withstand huge amounts of shell and torpedo damage because of a sophisticated damage control system which enabled massive amounts of water to either flood complete compartments such as magazines, or totally drain compartments badly holed and taking in water. This damage control system was rigorously practised by the crews, who each year had to take part in a flooding exercise which actually included filling up a few compartments. The experience that this gave the crews paid off handsomely later on at the battle of Jutland.

One of the Konig's massive portholes.

One of the Konig’s massive portholes.

The Konig’s armament was awesome. Five armoured turrets, each containing two twelve inch guns could all be fired on the centreline, delivering a broadside that totalled over nine thousand pounds. As well as these five turrets there were fourteen 5.9 inch guns arranged down her sides, four 3.9 single anti aircraft guns, three torpedo tubes fitted at the bows and two at the stern each carrying up to ten torpedoes. It was no wonder that Rear Admiral Behneke chose the Konig to be his ‘flagship’ when he led his battlefleet to its historic confrontation with the Royal Navy at the battle of Jutland.

Alas for the Konig those heady days of glory lasted only a few short years. How the Battlefleets maneuvered and the politicians postured is now history. For the Konig and the rest of her kind, oblivion came on the 21st June 1919 when at Scapa Flow they pulled out the seacocks and deliberately sunk one of the mightiest battlefleets the world had ever seen. "Disgraceful" and "humiliating" have been some of the adjectives used to describe that memorable event. But if the scuttling was meant to save the German Navy’s honour, then it might be argued that they succeeded, for when you clap eyes on one of these gigantic ships you just cannot fail to admire them and wonder about the people who built and fought in them.

Another view of the Konig.

Another view of the Konig.

Nowadays the Konig lies in just over 100 feet of water, heeled right over on her side. On the day we dived on her the shot rope had bedded into the sand, and so what we were looking at was the bottom of the hull. In order to get to the main deck we had to swim fifty or sixty feet back up the hull until suddenly we reached the edge of a steel precipice. Looking down we could see the main deck plunging back into the murk, like the outside of a block of flats. As we carefully swam down, the first thing we saw was a huge gun turret, completely intact. As we swam around it, puffing air in our excitement, there, off to the left was another turret and what looked like another smaller gun. It was absolutely fantastic. There were these huge guns hanging sideways on a vast plain of metal, looking so real that at any moment you expected them to start swiveling.

One of the Konig's smaller guns.

One of the Konig’s smaller guns.

After the turrets we came across the after mast and one of the ‘fighting tops’ that were used to spot the fall of shot. These again were intact if a trifle full of iron rubbish. Still some voice pipes are still there, and there are lots of brass tallies and wheels with German labels and it is very easy to get in and out. Once away from the masts we found some smaller guns in open mountings, which looked like anti aircraft guns and seemed almost ready to fire with their brass calibration rings and breach blocks still dully shining in the clear water.

As we left the guns, we began to realise that the sheer size of this ship just has to be seen to be believed. In fact you really ‘feel’ it rather than see it, because the ship is so vast. With time and air rapidly diminishing we swam back along the top (actually the side) of the hull along lines of gaping portholes set in a gigantic iron plain that seemed to roll on forever. There is no question about it, the Konig is without doubt one of the greatest wrecks I have ever seen. She’s got size and she has got atmosphere and she has still got a lot of secrets. I only saw about a third of this ship and I hate to think what I might have missed. Still it gives me a good excuse to have another go and if you ever get up that way, I strongly recommend that you do too.

Koln – a German Light Cruiser

On the 21st November 1918 the German High Sea’s Fleet formally surrendered to the British Navy and were interned at Britain’s largest and bleakest anchorage, Scapa Flow. Amongst the fleet of captive ships was the light cruiser Koln which had only been completed about twelve months previously. One of the Karlsruhe class of cruisers, the Koln was officially classed by the German Navy as a small protected cruiser and to that end was equipped with eight 5.9 inch guns, two 50 calibre anti aircraft guns and four torpedo tubes, two underwater and two situated on deck just forward of the middle funnel.

The Light Cruiser Koln.

The Light Cruiser Koln.

The Koln was fast, easy to steer, but leaked like a sieve in any sort of rough weather. The crew’s quarters were appalling, cramped and badly ventilated with virtually nowhere to hang or dry clothing. The men slept on a ‘hot bunk’ system, the off watch members sleeping in the duty men’s beds. In fact crew accommodation was really an after thought, the main consideration was always weaponry and ammunition storage. It was quite common to have food stacked in the passage ways and cooking facilities were extremely rudimentary. The reason for these awful conditions was the difference in the attitude of the German Navy. Their ships were hardly ever at sea for extended periods, unlike the British who had, at the time, a huge worldwide fleet, so their ships did not have the necessary facilities. The German sailors did not mind too much because the lack of sea time gave them more time ashore, so they were reasonably content with the situation.

Peering into one of the holds.

Peering into one of the holds.

However once interned in Scapa Flow and forced to live aboard permanently, the Koln’s shortcoming became horribly apparent. Personal hygiene became almost non-existent due to the lack of enough water and the least said about the toilet facilities the better. Since their own food rations and spare equipment were soon used up, the German crews became dependant for absolutely everything on the British, who with their usual bureaucracy, fouled things up. There was never enough food or drinking water and of course no coal. Without coal there was no means of generating power and so the Koln became an inert lump of freezing, insanitary metal. Her crew, close to despair, grabbed at the one chance that would enable them to not only better their miserable conditions, but also embarrass and humiliate the British. The idea was quite simple and the German sailors seized their opportunity and scuttled the entire High Seas Fleet, including the light cruiser Koln.

Nowadays the Koln, like so many of the other vessels, lies on her side in about 105 feet of water. The visibility at this depth is usually very good and as you fall down the anchor rope you soon see the huge bulk of this once proud ship emerge from the darkness. Although largely intact, the Koln has now started to break up. There are not as many guns on her as on some other wrecks, nor is there as much brass in evidence, but she is extremely picturesque. We landed on the forward part of the ship and swam at first over to the bows past the main anchor capstans and what looked like a gun mounting spindle. After poking around for a while, we then swam back to the bridge and saw the masts and rigging still intact, lying strung out across the sandy bottom. The crow’s nest was still in one piece and as we swam towards it, we saw attached to part of the rigging a large For Sale sign. It had not been there all that long, just long enough to gather some weed. I don’t know who put it there, but I bet the ‘old crew’ would have thought it very appropriate.

How Much ?

How Much ?

Further along was a large opening and peering inside we could see light coming in from the bottom of the ship some thirty feet below. As we swam down into this vast cavern, we could see, amidst the huge scrap yard of twisted metals, coils of lead covered wiring and a jumble of smashed up brass turbine blades. As we came out of the bottom hole onto the sand, we felt so pleased with ourselves that we just had to go and do it again. If only we had more time to explore the rest of the interior. Back up on deck we came to one of the more pretty parts of the wreck. One of the companionways stretching back aft from the bridge had become a jumble of broken railings and upright supports that had arranged themselves into a sort of iron tent, with lots of skylights. Pieces of seaweed clung to parts of the structure reflecting the sunlight onto the large anemones that proliferate on this wreck. The whole effect on a sunny day is quite spectacular and for a while it actually took my mind off looking for portholes. Talking of portholes, there are plenty of them about, but all the ones I saw were made of iron and they studded the outside of the huge hull like a rash of unsightly blisters. When viewed from the side, the vast iron walls, with their pockmarked craters, looked like something out of ‘Star Wars’.

Looking into a mass of iron pipes.

Looking into a mass of iron pipes.

Back on the sandy bottom we found more holes to peer into and a great mass of iron pipes with large brass end fittings. All around us were the remains of smashed in bulkheads, with their supports rearing up fifty feet or so to the surface. With the surface light shining through making weird patterns on the sand, you feel that really it is just too much. The sheer bulk of these ships just has to be seen to be appreciated. The huge walls of steel with their gaping cavernous holes just lead you on and on from one visual experience to another and even if you are not a wreck fanatic, you cannot help getting caught up in the experience. The Koln is not the best wreck in Scapa, but it is manageable and when you finish your dive on her at least you will have seen most of her and be prepared for the massive battle cruisers that lie just a bit further along the anchorage.


Special Report: Scapa Flow:

  • Overview: Scapa Flow – the German Valhalla
  • Brummer
  • Geleitboot F2
  • Koln
  • Konig

The Brummer -A German Light Cruiser

Of all the wrecks that I dived on in Scapa Flow the Brummer remains my favourite. It certainly is not the biggest, but for sheer dive sensation I believe that it typifies what it is like to dive on these fantastic wrecks.

Built at Stettin and launched in December 1915, the Brummer was a light cruiser of some four and a half thousand tons. Its main armament consisted of four 5.9 inch guns and she had a top speed of twenty eight knots. At 14.30 on the 21 June 1919 she was scuttled along with the rest of the German fleet at Scapa Flow. Well that’s the bare facts. It certainly tells you about the boat, but it does not tell you anything about the almost heart stopping sensation that you get when you first dive on this relic of a once mighty Navy. Words like awesome, incredible and unbelievable are just some that were used by the other divers on our boat, and they did not even begin to get near the effect that this wreck had on all of us. And remember, this is only a light cruiser, not one of the mighty Battleships.

The Brummer.

The Brummer.

For once I am not going to try and give you a dive report because I do not think that it would do you any good. The distances to the wrecks are long and you really need local knowledge to sort out the tides and unpredictable weather patterns. Marks are not really much good either, the ring of islands all look so alike that most of us were permanently disorientated for most of our visit. When the weather worsens even the local skippers have some difficulties in finding the wrecks, but when they do they almost always put you on the more interesting bits (like the gun turrets). this sort of expertise is rather important because if you have never seen a light cruiser before, and left’s face it, not many of us have, you could find yourself swimming the wrong way along a steel wall reminiscent of a twelve storey block of flats.

These wrecks are just huge.

These wrecks are just huge.

Today the Brummer lies on its side in one hundred feet of water. A ship this size, virtually intact and lying on its side takes some getting used to, and at first you tend to swim along with a crick in your neck. Fortunately however the visibility is excellent usually thirty foot or more, and once you see something like a gun turret it orientates you and then you can really start to enjoy your dive. As I said, thirty feet above the wreck, I saw a gun turret, and after examining that we swam into a mess deck. This was amazing. All the portholes, alas only Iron, were completely intact including the glass and deadlights. They were all just hanging open and as you swam along you just reached out and touched them and soon all the row of portholes were swinging to and fro.

Brass Turbine.

Brass Turbine.

It seems a bit childish now, but we just swam up and down swinging on those portholes, shouting, (or trying to) to each other in our excitement. Looking down the width of the ship you could see the lattice of ironwork that supported the upper deck. At various intervals, hatch and doorways leading to other parts of the ship were visible and it was looking down a huge lift shaft. Light glowed in from a double row of portholes on the ship’s hull, lighting up the interior and giving a truly awesome impression of size. We plunged down the lift shaft burbling away to each other and came out of the messdeck through a hole in the side of the hull and found ourselves on another gun turret. The minutes were ticking by, but we just had to have a look at it and then we found that we were right beside the bridge, its empty square windows looking like black pits in a huge wall of steel.

Post Card.

Post Card.

As we swam back to the shot we missed it and came across the mainmast, complete with its fighting top and crows nest, lying stretched out across the sand. You could swim into the fighting top and still see some of the tally’s on the now rusting control gear. Absolutely incredible, I just did not want to come up. But, when I finally had to surface, I still could not shake off the feeling of sheer power that this ship conveyed to me. In her day the Brummer was an awesome example of German sea power. Sixty seven years on that word still describes her and the dive – awesome.


Special Report: Scapa Flow:

  • Overview: Scapa Flow – the German Valhalla
  • Brummer
  • Geleitboot F2
  • Koln
  • Konig

S54 Destroyer

S54 was one of the S49 class of destroyers, and really very similar in size, speed and armament to the V83. She was launched on 11 October 1915 and when she tried to scuttle she was boarded, and they managed to beach her where she was finally broken up in 1921.

Probably not the S54, but you can see that this is how she was beached.

Probably not the S54, but you can see that this is how she was beached.

I dived this wreck in1985 and this is what I wrote in my notes.

This wreck lies in 50 ft and there is just scrap everywhere. Turbine blades, valve chests, you name it and its here. If you want to see brass on a wreck this is the place. The most noticeable are the engine turbine blades. You can’t miss them they just stick out of the main engine turbine. Trouble is they need a lot of work to remove, so its just as much fun looking. Besides that there is worming gear, valve chests, large pieces of sheet brass, lead and copper and then just loads more smashed up wreckage with more brass on it. Not only that it’s rather a pretty wreck as well, lying as it does on sand. It seems to be on various levels and you can rummage inside parts of the engine room, or just roam around the outside tripping over all that brass. It’s all well fixed. Still keep on banging.

Kronprinz Willhelm

The Kronprinz Willhelm was one of four Konig class battleships and was 575 ft in length, nearly 97 ft in the beam, and had a draught of just over 30 ft. her top speed was around 24 knots, and when she was involved in the Battle of Jutland she had a complement of nearly 1300 officers and men. Ironically her turbines were powered by fifteen huge boilers made by a partnership of two firms, Schulz-Thornycroft, which just shows that the Arm’s industry never missed a trick, even back then.

The Kronprinz Willhelm seen here steaming into line.

The Kronprinz Willhelm seen here steaming into line.

Her Armament was fearsome, including five twin turrets of 12 inch guns which were all placed on the centre line with super firing pairs fore and aft with the fifth turret stuck in between the funnels but still at the same height as the aft super firing one. Either side of her massive hull was fourteen 5.9 inch guns arranged in Barbettes, with another six 3.45 inch guns and an array of anti aircraft batteries.

The ship was originally launched at Kiel on 21 of February 1914 as just the Kronprinz, but on 27 January 1918 she was renamed the Kronprinz Willhelm. (presumably in honour of Crown Prince William)

Kronprinz showing her thick foremast.

Kronprinz showing her thick foremast.

I dived this wreck in 1985 and these are the notes that I wrote then.

The wreck lies in 110 ft but most of it is accessible in 75 ft. A Battleship that is lying on its side. Such a shame that the Germans could not sink something upright. The shot was at the back of the hull so you had to fin up this huge wall of steel to the side and then suddenly its all downhill 110 ft to the bottom. It’s just like a block of flats. Again the scale is so immense that you just can’t quite get it. For instance we found two brass deadlights over two feet in diameter. God knows what the whole assemblage of porthole, glass and deadlight weighed. They were well fixed but even so were an amazing sight. After that we found that we were on the wrong part for the main turrets, but we saw a barrel of one of the side guns lying on the sand, the turret being recessed into the huge steel plating. Brass valves, big ones, were sticking out of the sand, and soon we came across a huge twisted amount of metal, then it was time to swim up to the side and along one of the four huge bilge keels. Very very impressive, but not really photographic because there is nothing to give any scale. It’s all so bloody huge.

Kronprinz firing a broadside.

Kronprinz firing a broadside.

Karlruhe

The Karlsruhe was one of four Konigsberg (ii) class of Light cruisers, and should not be confused with the Karlsruhe Light Cruiser class of which there were two one being named the Karlsruhe. She was sunk on 4th November 1914. The Imperial German navy had a very confusing ship naming policy and it’s easy to research the wrong ship.

Anyway our Karlsruhe was laid down in 1915 and launched on 3rd January 1916.She had a complement of 475 officers and men and a top speed of 30 knots. This was provided by 2-shaft high-pressure navy turbines, powered by twelve boilers, ten coal and two oil fired. The Karlruhe was 478 ft long, nearly 47 ft in the beam and had a draught of 19 ft 8 inches. Her armament included eight 5.9-inch guns, three 3.45-inch guns, four batteries of 50mm anti aircraft guns, and she could also lay up to 120 mines.

I first dived this wreck in 1985 and this is what I wrote in my notes at the time.

The Karlsruhe lies in about 80 ft of water well broken up on a sandy bottom. Even so the first thing to hit you is the sheer size of the wreck. You just do not realise how big a light cruiser is until you see something like this with its huge ‘walls’ of steel. Access into the engine hold is easy, but they are vast caverns stuffed full of brass or lead. Easier are the huge gashes revealing a scrap yard of twisted metal and a jumble of bright brass turbine blades. Lead cable is coiled everywhere and seems quite commonplace after a while. One of the pretty bits was one of the companion ways with its upright supports and broken railings making a sort of iron tent, with bits of weed floating artistically around. Plumose anemones abound, but overshadowing all it is the sheer massive bulk of the wreck Huge iron portholes stud the iron walls and the whole thing viewed from the side looks like something from Star Wars. A really great dive.

In October 1997 I made another visit to the Kalsruhe, and still was not disappointed. This time the skipper put us right on the bow near the forward turret. After examining that (my first love) I swam along the deck looking into all the holes and hatchways, and sometimes going inside to see the great festoons of electric cable lying all over the place. At the bow the anchor windlasses are still there complete with anchor chain. The next really noticeable thing was the wooden decking and the Anemones. As always tons of brass, and far too much to look at in the time. It’s a very, very impressive wreck.

The Geleitboot F2

Scapa Flow, the largest and most godforsaken of all the harbours ever used by the Royal Navy, is the scene of one of the most extraordinary naval episodes in history – the scuttling of an entire German High Seas battle fleet.

On 21 June 1919, eleven battleships, six battle cruisers, eight light cruisers and fifty destroyers slowly turned over and sank to the bottom of the sea. Although some were subsequently raised and others were partly salvaged, many more remain lying in the clear and rainlashed water that surges between the windswept islands making up the anchorage of Scapa Flow.

Scapa Flow Postcard.

Scapa Flow Postcard.

This is awesome diving, The sheer size of wonderships like the Konig and the Brummer are almost indescribable. And the fact that most are still intact right down to their portholes and guns leaves the wrecker almost speechless with delight.

Other wrecks are merely fantastic. Our boatful of divers voted the wreck of the F2 one of the most popular wrecks to dive. This was mainly because it was all so accessible and because people were not overawed by its scale.

Strangely enough, the F2 was not a victim of the events of 1919 at all. In fact, she was not even built until the start of the Second World War. And she was wrecked more by the carelessness on the part of the British than for any other reason.

The Geleitboot F2.

The Geleitboot F2.

The F2 was built in 1935 by Germania as an escort vessel or Geleitboot of 756 tons. She was 249 feet long, twenty nine feet wide and had a very shallow draught of only just over eight feet. Unlike the Royal Navy, the Germans did not name all their ships, tending instead to christen only the biggest and the best. Lesser vessels like destroyers and escort vessels were designated instead by a letter and a number.

With two geared turbines, she could reach speeds of over twenty eight knots. For her crew of 124 this must have been purgatory. Although excellent sea boats, they were also incredibly wet and uncomfortable. They were not really designed to house a crew for long periods. Any heavy weather and the inside of the F2 would have been a real morale buster, even compared with the lower standards of their day.

Hard Hat Divers at work.

Hard Hat Divers at work.

As well as being fast, the F2 also packed a sizeable punch. It had a 4.1 50 calibre gun mounted fore and aft, four 37mm machine guns and two one pounder guns for defence against aircraft attack. In addition, there wee also two sets of depth charge throwers for submarine attack.

If all that wasn’t enough, she could also be rigged for mine laying. All in all the F2 was a very useful and versatile ship, and it is not surprising that the Germans built scores of them. The F2 survived the war, and when the Germans surrendered, she was given to the British as part of their war reparations. The British took her to Scapa Flow in December 1946 to await further instructions as to her fate.

Inside the Gun Turret.

Inside the Gun Turret.

Quite what happened next is not clear. Suffice to say that she sank on 13 December 1946 in the channel between the islands of Hoy and Fara. She was not considered worthy of salvage. The F2 soon became a total loss. Most of the F2 today lies in just fifty feet of water. With the viz usually in excess of thirty feet, the sight of this wreck is staggering. The ship lies on her side, but the bows are completely intact with an entire 4.1 gun mounting still there. The gun seemed almost to be in working order, You can easily get right inside the gun mounting and look out through the gun slits, just as if you were part of the gun crew. Lying there on your side in the turret produces an optical illusion that makes the boat stand upright. There right in front of you are the bows flaring away, perfect in every detail.

Just back from the gun mounting are the remains of the bridge, which forms a huge overhanging cave as it sets onto the seabed. You can get inside, but it is a bit dark and a tight fit. If you poke your head underneath, you can avoid any potential embarrassment but still get the full flavour or what it would have been like.

Looking down into the tangle at the stern.

Looking down into the tangle at the stern.

Further back is the stern, all smashed up with iron plating everywhere. There’s masses of piping, broken stanchions, electrical cable and all manner of mangled bits and pieces. There should be another gun mounting, but I didn’t see one. This area is really interesting and if you have time, it is well worth a thorough examination, especially out on the sand just away from the wreck. There is plenty of broken pottery here, some with German markings.

Time starts to run out, but it is the bows and the guns that call you back for one last look. It really is a most magnificent sight.

As an encore, if the rest of your gang has not stirred up the sand too much, try this. Fin slowly towards the surface directly above the gun. When you get about ten feet from the surface, hold it and look back down. And remember the view – because there is nowhere else in the world where you can see anything quite like it. Fantastic!

Special Report: Scapa Flow:

  • Overview: Scapa Flow – the German Valhalla
  • Brummer
  • Geleitboot F2
  • Koln
  • Konig

Dressden

The Dressden was one of the Coln class of Light Cruisers, laid down in Kiel in 1916 and launched on 24th Arpil 1917. This class was an improved version of the Konigsberg class, and were the start of an ambitious programme of ten vessels that were to be built to plug the gaps left by war losses. However due to material and manpower shortages, only seven were ever launched, and of those only two were actually completed and commissioned.

This is the Coln, same class as the Dressden, so a good look a like.

This is the Coln, same class as the Dressden, so a good look a like.

The Dressden, (not to be confused with the Dressden class of Light Cruisers of which there were two, the Dressden and the Emden of Von Spee fame. This Dressden was scuttled off Chile) was 510 ft overall, 46 ft 11 inches in the beam with a top speed of 27 knots. Her armarment was the same as the Karlesruhe.

I dived this wreck in Oct 1997 and this is what I wrote in my notes.

This is another huge wreck lying on its side in about 32 meters. There is loads of brass on this wreck and with the vis nearly 30 ft we went straight into the engine room and had a great root around. I then swam towards the forward gun and then down towards the stern where we found some huge thrust blocks. On the second dive we went from the gun towards the bow, inside the open bridge and then out onto the fighting top that was lying out across the bottom. We then swam on to the bow then back along the top of the wreck over the bilge keels. The hull was covered with plumose anemones. Again its hard to get a handle on a wreck this size, but what fun trying.

H.M.N.Z.S. Waikato

On 25th November 2000 H.M.N.Z.S. Waikato was deliberately sunk two miles south of Tutukaka in Ngunguru Bay as an attraction for visiting divers. New Zealand has something of a habit of doing this. The country has sunk around 5 assorted frigates, and nearby is the oceanographic vessel Tui, sunk in … I was lucky to dive this wreck three years later so she was almost pristine and I was very glad of the opportunity, because we were about to sink a frigate of the same class in Whitsands Bay near Plymouth. She is called the Scylla, and was to be Britain’s first artificial reef. I was eager to see what we might expect.

Getting ready.

Getting ready.

The Waikato was a Leander Class Frigate, and the first one to be built for the New Zealand Navy. She was built by the Belfast firm of Harland and Wolfe, and was launched by Princess Alexandra on the 18th Feb 1965. She was just over 350 ft long, was around 36 ft in the beam and displaced 3182 tonnes. As an anti-submarine frigate, the Waikato was armed with twin 4.5in guns in one turret, two 20mm Orlikeon machine guns on the wings, a quad Seacat anti-aircraft missile launcher, six 12.75in anti-submarine torpedo tubes, one anti-submarine warfare Limbo mortar Mark 10 and a Wasp helicopter capable of delivering both depth charges and the Mark 46 anti-submarine torpedo. She had a top speed of just under 30 knots, and a ship complement of 239 men, including 19 officers. The ship took its name from the North Island Province of Waiato and was the first New Zealand Navy vessel to adopt this name.

Down she goes.

Down she goes.

The Waiato had a relatively peaceful life, but she was instrumental in rescuing a US Navy Sea King helicopter which was losing power and running out of fuel. Her small flight deck wasn’t designed for such a large aircraft to land, but she managed, saving the crew and the aircraft. In 1970 she had a major fire in her engine room, and the enquiry into this led to the Navy completely changing its procedures for combating fire, and rethinking part of their Damage Control. During the Falklands War she was stationed in the Indian Ocean to relieve a Royal Navy ship carrying anti missile weapons. In July 1998 she was decommissioned, and a new life beckoned.

Life in the Plotting Room.

Life in the Plotting Room.

At first this new life didn’t seem up to much and consisted of being a viewing platform for the America’s Cup races. Soon however she was purchased by the Tutukaka Promotions Society so that she cold be sunk as an artificial reef and an attraction to divers. After five months of stripping and cleaning the Waikato was ready for her big day and was towed to an area off the Tutukaka Heads. On November 25 th 2000,just after mid day, Rob Snelling who had won a raffle for the honour, hit the detonator and twelve large holes were blown in her hull. With thousands of people watching on land and sea ,down she went. Her end took just two and a half minutes.

In her heyday.

In her heyday.

Now the Lleanders, have a known weakness, which is just behind the turret, and in front of the bridge. As the Waiato plunged to the bottom, her bow hit the seabed, and as her stern followed, the bow fell off. So now the Waikato lies with her bottom in 28 metres with a list to port with her bow completely separated. This has actually made for a much better diving experience, as you don’t often she a ship neatly cut in two. Unlike the Scylla, they have left the gun turret on, as well as the funnel, and only hacked off that part of the radar mast that would have stuck out of the water. At its shallowest, the Waikayo is only 8 metres below the surface. So what’s she like to dive?

Ships Crest.

Ships Crest.

I really enjoyed this wreck, even though it was sunk deliberately. The wreck is basically upright with the bow seperated from the wreck but very nearby. You go down the radar mast and then you can swim out to the bow which for me was the best bit of the wreck as I have never seen a completely detached bow before. Coming back you go to the stern and swim through the helicopter hangar and then into the bridge. Just before the bows breaks off there is a twin turret with the guns still attached. very nice. The vis was about 60ft and the the whole thing was very nice, if a bit antiseptic.Still if you are over on a trip its well worth doing.

The Thistlegorm

The Thislegorm was built by Joseph Thompson and Sons of Sunderland, and was launched in June 1940. Originally built for the Albyn Line she was taken over almost immediately for war service and designated as an Armed Freighter. She was just a shade over 410 ft long , displaced 4898 tons, and was armed with an old heavy calibre machine gun and a 4.7 gun fitted on to a sort of armoured deck that had been hastily constructed over the aft section of the ship. These weapons were completely useless against anything more than a passing rowing boat and were wisely left alone until the Thislegorm’s second voyage to South America to collect a cargo of grain.

Panorama. (photo Peter Rowlands)

Panorama. (photo Peter Rowlands)

Since conditions were calm and boredom was getting the upper hand, Captain Ellis decided to liven up the crew with a little live firing. At first all went well with the first round disappearing nicely into the distance. The second round however jammed in the breach and misfired. When a round misfires, it often means that it has become live and just needs a nudge. In order to do this with a modicum of safety the gun grew attached a rope to the trigger and retired to the mast house, well behind the aft superstructure. This was just as well, as when the trigger was pulled, the resulting gun flash enveloped the entire stern, with the shell just managing to fall into the water.

The Bow. (photo Peter Rowlands)

The Bow. (photo Peter Rowlands)

In May 1941 The Thislegorm was in Glasgow loading essential supplies for the Army at Tobruk. Although the manifest said that she was just carrying Motor Transport supplies she was also carrying large amounts of ammunition, land mines and the like, bren gun carriers, lorries, motor bikes, armoured cars, aircraft and spares for all of those items as well as radio’s and boots. On deck were two sets of rolling stock for the Egyptian Railways, comprising two engines, two tenders and two water carriers. To save some space so that they could cram in even more supplies, the motor bikes were stored in the back of the trucks.

The Hold. (photo Peter Rowlands)

The Hold. (photo Peter Rowlands)

On the 2 June the Thislegorm left Glasgow and sailed down to the South Coast to redevous with the convoy that would hopefully deliver her safely to Africa. Three weeks later Captain Ellis dropped anchor at the entrance to the Suez Canal to await permission to go on up to Alexandria. The Thislegorm’s anchorage was considered quite safe. There were no enemy ships nearby and the Lutwaffe rarely put in an appearance. Unfortunately two ships using the Canal collided and the resulting chaos took ages to sort out leaving the Thislegorm stuck at anchor for two weeks and right in the way of a very important troop convoy. The Germans got wind of the convoy and thought it might be the Queen Mary carrying 1200 British troops. The Luttewaffe sent up two Heinkel HE 111 from a base in Crete and ordered them to search for the Troop Ship.

My favorite gun. (photo Peter Rowlands)

My favorite gun. (photo Peter Rowlands)

For hours the planes searched in vain and were on the point of returning to base when they saw the Thislegorm. The lead plane flew low towards the bow and released two bombs that struck the Thislegorm in No 5 hold just aft of the Bridge. The bombs detonated tons of the ammunition stored in the hold and the resulting blast tore the ship open, peeling bac the aft decks and hurling the two locomotives onto the seabed. The vessel began to sink very quickly, and with no time to launch the life boats most of the crew just jumped straight into the sea. One man however got trapped in the blazing ruins and started shouting for help. Crewman Angus McLeay wrapped some wet rags around his bare feet and raced across the burning deck managing to drag the man to safety. For his courage McLeay was later awarded the George Medal and Lloyds added their War Medal for Bravery at Sea.

The train. (photo Peter Rowlands)

The train. (photo Peter Rowlands)

The Thislegorm sank on the 6th October 1941 at around half past one in the morning. She took nine of the crew with her. Captain Ellis survived to fight another day and was awarded an OBE. For many years the remains of the Thislegorm lay undisturbed until Jacques Cousteau Came across it in the fifties.( you can read his account of his exploration of the Thislegorm in The Living Sea) He raised one of the Motor Bikes and the ships bell, and he found the builders plate, but as he did not reveal the ships position, the Thislegorm faded back into obscurity until quite by chance, a group of divers found her in the Nineties.


This great video, by Peter Rowlands

Dive report. Many say that this is the best wreck dive in the world. I am not one of them, but I will admit that she is a stunning wreck. The trouble is that she is just too popular, and you will be lucky to dive on her with less than fifty other divers. So much so, that she has become known as the champagne wreck because the bubbles that the divers leave behind are always fizzing out of her.

This is the only dive I did on this wreck and I must say I was impressed. Its got a gun on the stern, loads of trucks, motorbikes and rifles inside, and bits of a train set lying around outside the wreck. Visibility is about 60ft so you have no difficulty seeing everything, except that hoards of divers almost obscure your view. Luckily my companion had dived this wreck before so off we went deep inside the wreck where we managed to loose most of the other divers. We both squeezed through a small hole and found ourselves in the inside of a huge iron cave, with light streaming in from jagged holes above. The whole thing was packed with hatchet fish and as we drifted along we saw the trucks and a motobike, and someone’s bath.

After that we had a good look at the gun, a quick flash of the prop, and then it was back to the bow to find our boat’s rope and be blown to the surface on clouds of divers bubbles.

H.M.S. Port Napier

1941, and the biggest threat in the Atlantic besides submarines and the savage gales, were the surface raiders Tirpitz and Bismark. In an effort to contain these ‘super ships’, the Admiralty decided to block the passage between Iceland and Shetland with huge minefields, and to that end requisitioned merchant ships from the Port and Prince shipping Companies. One of those ships was the Port Napier, a brand new twin screw diesel ship built for the meat trade with New Zealand. After being taken over she was rapidly converted to a mine layer, with two inch thick armour plating being added to her sides, and armed with two four inch guns on her forecastle, together with various anti aircraft weapons. Magazines were fitted, and the necessary hoists and winches installed to load and launch the six hundred mines that she could now carry.

The mine laying squadron that she joined was based at the Kyle of Loch Alsh, and in 1941 they were hard at work mining the vast gap to the north of Shetland. On November 27 th, the Port Napier, along with the rest of her squadron loaded up with mines in preparation for sailing that night. Now in those days it was common practice to insert the detonator into the mine whilst still in harbour, as it was often very difficult to do so on the deck of a heaving ship in heavy weather. By late evening the port Napier had fully armed most of her six hundred mines, and since they were due to sail shortly everything should have been perfectly safe. As luck would have it however, a fierce gale blew up and funnelled down the Loch catching the Port Napier unprepared, and she started to drag her anchors. An eleven thousand ton ship filled with mines dragging her anchors in a howling gale is no easy thing to manoeuvre, especially in a confined space. Very quickly the Port Napier was careering completely out of control, and soon she smashed into an anchored collier who’s anchor chain fouled her propellers.

The Wreck is lying with one side showing.

The Wreck is lying with one side showing.

With both engines stopped the Port Napier and the hapless collier continued to drag right across the Loch towards the Isle of Skye, where finally their combined anchors got a grip and brought them up safely in a shallow bay close to the shore. The next morning the Port Napier started the job of clearing her propellers and it was decided that they might as well complete her refuelling while they were at it. Halfway through the refuelling a fire started in the engine room and within minutes it was completely out of control. With the engine room a raging inferno, attention was concentrated on the two mine decks directly above the engine room, which of course were full of armed mines. Whilst the rest of the crew abandoned ship, the mine party , with almost unbelievable courage, went back to the mine decks and started to remove the detonators.

Recovering a mine. Very Health and Safety.

Recovering a mine. Very Health and Safety.

After about twenty minutes the lower mine deck became white hot and it became obvious that the ship could not be saved. The mining party was ordered off the ship, and the Port Napier was left to burn. After a while the fire seemed to die down and once again a party of volunteers scrambled back on board to see what could be saved. Once on board however the crew found that the fire was burning just as fiercely and moreover the mine decks above the engine room were now starting to buckle in the heat. The volunteers started to chuck mines down the stern chutes, but soon the heat and smoke became to much for them to endure and so they had to abandon ship once again. They were not a moment to soon. As they safely cleared the ship there were two huge explosions. The first blew bits of the ship onto the Isle of Skye, some going two hundred feet into the air, and the other explosion shot a huge column of smoke and flames that mushroomed out over the Loch like a dark stain.

Down the barrel of a gun.

Down the barrel of a gun.

As people on both sides of the Loch watched in morbid fascination, the Port Napier slowly rolled over onto her starboard side and came to rest in seventy feet of cold green water. With her back broken, and about one hundred feet of her port side blown away they was no hope of salvage, so she was abandoned where she lay. Today the Port Napier still lies in the little bay where she was abandoned. She is easy to find as bits of her stick out of the water at most states of the tide. The great thing about this wreck, is that because most of her port side plates are missing, you can penetrate deep into the wreck without fear of being trapped. All you have to do is look up, and there is the surface light shinning down through the wreckage showing you your way out.

You can just see the 'amatol soup' pouring out of the mine.

You can just see the ‘amatol soup’ pouring out of the mine.

Because it is such a big wreck you really need to concentrate on one end or another, and have two or more dives if at all possible. The water is very clear and visibility is usually twenty five feet or more with virtually no current. The bow of this ship is amazing as it is completely intact with the starboard side still held well clear of the bottom, so you can swim right underneath it. Because the ship is on its side it takes a bit of getting used to, but you soon pick out the winches, bollards, and best of all the four inch gun which is more or less intact with lots of well polished brass that just will not come off. Surprisingly the wooden deck covering is still intact, covered in white tube anemones, and is a great site with most of the forepeak railings still hanging in place. All the hatches and doors are still there and most hang open giving access to electrical machine spaces and gangways inside the ship.

A bit murky inside.

A bit murky inside.

Further back towards mid ships we entered the wreck and swam down a great iron tunnel, probably one of the mine chutes, and came out of a hatch in the forecastle onto the main deck. Incidentally the second four inch gun is right on the surface covered in so much weed that you can easily pass it by. The stern section is a real eye opener. The prop shafts are still there and so is the opening where the mines were discharged overboard on that fateful night. Inside these chutes you could see right up through the decks, a misty green light filtering down towards you. Because there was no danger of being trapped we swam right along the mine chute, then down into some huge machinery spaces. All around were great pieces of machinery jumbles up with broken pipes and smashed up metal, all covered with a deep layer of silt.

Just a part of the ship that was blown all over the Loch.

Just a part of the ship that was blown all over the Loch.

Further down into the ship we came upon another machine space, and on the other side of this we could see a small oblong of green light which we carefully swam towards. It turned out to be a small hatch in the stern covered with a broken railing. A bit of gentle manoeuvring and we were back out of the ship and into open water. Absolutely incredible. I could go on about the clouds of scallops, and the shoals of other fish which festoon this wreck and not dwell to long on the seals and the huge pieces of wreckage that were blown onto the nearby beach, but it would all pale into insignificance against the sheer quality of this wreck. After a couple of years fighting the weather and cold, a lot of divers seem to loose some of their original enthusiasm. If you are one of these, get yourself up to the Kyle of Loch Alsh and rekindle your spirit on a truly great wreck.

S.S.Liberty

In the early sixties Bali was devastated when the Mount Agung volcano erupted killing hundreds of people and sweeping away whole villages. The Balinese however took it all in their stride. Even today they are a devoutly religious people, and still most build shrines to their ancestors or Gods before they think of building their own homes. So they just kept faith with their Hindu Gods, and today, at the top of the still smoking volcano is a modern restaurant sporting a horde of very persuasive young souvenir sellers. I have always wanted to go up an active volcano so I was in my element. What I did not know, was down on the other side of the volcano where it swept into the sea, was a shipwreck that was the spitting image of probably the best known wreck in England, the James Egan Layne.

S.S.Liberty.

S.S.Liberty.

The Balinese Authorities have long since realised that their own way of life is well worth protecting, and so most of the tourist hotels lie in one area of the island leaving the rest of Bali relatively unspoilt. It is a fascinating island. Its people are probably the most beautiful on earth and are certainly the most gentle. The whole island is steeped in antiquity, most of the great temples date back over a thousand years, and its landscape has been virtually moulded over the centuries by its farmers terracing the steep mountain land into patchworks of green plots sprinkled with intricate irrigation systems to grow most of their food. The people mostly live in extended villages, with most of the activity happening outside on the edge of the narrow roads that seem to run endlessly throughout the island.

The culture goes back thousands of years.

The culture goes back thousands of years.

The diving to the front of Sanur beach is pleasant, but to my mind rather boring, so when the guide mentioned a shipwreck on the other side of the island I was all ears. Locally the wreck was called the Liberty. I certainly thought that it was a Liberty ship but I never did find out what its real name was. Unfortunately it was a four hour drive around to the other side of the island and the guide would not go unless I could find a partner. Luckily I found a German who was keen to go. He could not speak much English and my German is non existent so we had to resort to sign language. This was just as well, because the guide thought he cold speak both languages, but was in fact incomprehensible to both of us. Still they say that diving has its own international language and this must be so, because at seven o’clock the next morning we were all in a VW combi van full up with diving gear heading for the other side of the island. After two hours the scenery had lost some of its magic as the jarring and bumping from the roads, some not much better than tracks started to take effect. As the sun brightened to its full power, the VW heated up like a cauldron and by the time we finally got near the dive site we were beginning to wonder if it was all going to be worth it.

The water is gin clear.

The water is gin clear.

As we approached the bottom of the volcano however, our spirits revived. The lava, although long since solidified, still smoked, and you could see exactly where the massive lava flows have swept across roads and bridges straight into the sea. The whole area is completely devoid of the normally lush vegetation, and the air is still quite thick with sulphurous gases. When the VW finally stopped we were still about half a mile from the dive site, and I must confess that I did not like the thought of struggling with all my gear across the rest of the lava to the beach in the by now wilting heat. Luckily, from around the next corner emerged a bunch of young children from a nearby village. They had obviously seen discouraged divers before, and after a bit of high spirited haggling, they stripped the VW of all its gear, popped most of it on their heads, and loped off giggling across the lava down to the beach. When we finally caught up with them, they had placed all the gear neatly on the rocks and were busy making three little palm leaf rafts filled with different coloured orchids. When they were ready, the children, suddenly solemn, led the three of us to the water’s edge, and amid much seriousness the three flower rafts were pushed out to sea in the direction of the wreck. It was their way of wishing us a safe dive. It was completely spontaneous, very charming, and very Balinese.

They seem to carry anything this way.

They seem to carry anything this way.

The water was flat calm and crystal clear, and as we swam out towards the reef we were surrounded by shoals of small iridescent blue and yellow fish. The bottom was made up of petrified rock and after about fifty yards it started to slope and then abruptly plunged to ninety feet. The wreck was sat more or less upright, right against the side of the reef which made depth control very easy, and the near eighty foot visibility meant that nobody would get lost. Right away I felt at home. Apart from the clouds of brightly coloured fish, I could have been on a Saturday afternoon dive on the Egan Layne. It was quite uncanny the way I kept coming across features that I recognised, and soon I became completely orientated. This was just as well because this ‘Liberty’ has one feature that is different from the Egan Layne, and that is brass, tons of it. Great valve chests with whopping great brass wheels, long copper pipes with big brass fittings, and down in the engine room it was like a scrapper’s supermarket. I was amazed, and because I ‘knew’ my way around the ship I could go and look in all the best places. I had always wondered what the ‘Layne’ would have looked like before the salvors got to her, now I have a pretty good idea. When we surfaced I could hardly wait to get back down for the second dive.

This time the guide let me lead, and of we went on a magical dive through the holds, up around the wrecked superstructure, and down over the side to the bottom of the hull just like we do at home. Also like home, the wreck is covered almost wall to wall with shoals of fish, just as friendly and eager for hand held food as those on the ‘Layne’, but of course so brightly coloured that they can make your eyes ache after a while, especially with the bright sunlight bouncing off their scales. All too soon it was all over and our little helpers were presenting us with orchids for our ears. ( The orchids grow like weeds on Bali. If you are married, you wear yours behind your right ear) More orchids were scattered on the sea to thank the Gods for our safe return, and as the ebbing tide carried them out to the wreck we clambered back over the lava to the waiting VW. The Balinese consider their volcano to be The Navel of the Universe, a place for spirits, and a possible entrance to that place that we in the West call Heaven. It’s nice to now that there are still going to be wrecks to dive on in the afterlife, that’s assuming we all get there of course.

The divers are mobbed by fish.

The divers are mobbed by fish.

I dived this shipwreck in March 1987, and the preceeding article is what I wrote then. At the time I thought that it was a Liberty ship, and everyone that dived on it thought that it was too. It was only some years later when I started reading up on this ship, that I realised that all was not as I had assumed. A quick look around the lists of Liberty ships soon revealed that this boat was not one of them, but possibly an earlier ship. More digging found that this ship was in fact the S.S. Liberty built in 1918 by the Federal Shipbuilding Yard in New Jersey U.S.A. She was 411 feet long, 55 feet in the beam with a gross tonnage of 6211 tons.( internally she was rather like the Layne)She was built by order of the United States Shipping Board and served the U.S.Navy until 1919. After that she was either laid up or more likely was chartered by various companies to haul a mix of general cargo. At the outbreak of the Second World War she was requisition by the U.S.Army.

Brass.

Brass.

On Jan 11th 1942 she was on her way from Australia to the Philiphines carrying a cargo of railway parts and rubber when she was torpedoed in the Lombok Straits by the Japanese submarine 1-66 . She was taken in tow by two U.S. Navy destroyers who tried to tow her to the port of Singaraja. However the torpedo had done too much damage and with the Liberty taking on massive amounts of water it was decided to run her aground at Tulamben Bay. ( it’s quite strange that her sinking and grounding almost mirror what happened to the James Egan Layne) For twenty one years she stayed on the beach being gradually stripped of anything useful by the locals until the eruption of Mount Agung pushed her into the sea where she lies today.

Nowadays you don’t have to clamber over lava or carry your kit very far, as there is a dive shop and a caf?on the beach. The wreck itself is still a great dive, but according to the dive operators parts of it have become quite unstable, and bits collapse every year. Still for photographers its still a paradise as the wreck is covered with over 400 different species of fish .

www.waterworxbali.com

Strassa

The Strasser was an ore carrier built in Stockholm in 1921. On Arpil 6th 1940, the Strassa left Narvik harbour bound for Baltimore in the U.S.A. with a cargo of iron ore and a crew of thirty four men. When she reached the Lofoten Islands the Strassa started to have problems with her cooling system and since repairs could not be carried out at sea the Captain decided to return to Narvik. Here she laid at anchor in Tjeldsundet until April 9th, when she was ordered by the German Destroyer Dieter Von Roeder to proceed into Narvik harbour and await further orders.

The Swedish Ore Carrier Strassa.

The Swedish Ore Carrier Strassa.

She was still waiting for those orders the next day when the British Destroyers swept into the harbour sinking everything in sight. At the height of the battle the Strassa was hit, and the crew wisely abandoned her and got safely to the shore, leaving the Strassa to sink when she now lies in the harbour today.

The wreck of the Strassa.

The wreck of the Strassa.

This is a big wreck, on the same scale as the J.E.Layne. We swam down to the bow, saw the anchor, then swam down the starboard side along a terrific companion way, and then into a hold with lots of portholes, one of which still had its glass in. Back on deck there were loads of winches and many other bits and pieces of defunct machinery.

Part of the deck superstructure. (Photo F. Bang)

Part of the deck superstructure. (Photo F. Bang)

In the crew quarters we found a bath half full of silt. there were many other big, dark holes to go into, but our torches packed up so we had to forgo that pleasure.This wreck is attached by a thin line to another wreck (Martha Heinrick Fisher) which we will do later. Viz 25 ft but overcast.

A ghostly light inside. (Photo F. Bang)

A ghostly light inside. (Photo F. Bang)

Good wreck this, and on the second dive, to do the Martha Heinrick Fisher,(you have to swim along the Strassa) we all commented that we all enjoyed it far more than the first time. I think we were all wanting to do a destroyer for our first dive, and so were a bit disapointed to be doing an ore carrier.

Aproaching the Strassa. (Photo F. Bang)

Aproaching the Strassa. (Photo F. Bang)

Romanby

The Romanby was originally an English ship built at Harlepool in 1927. On the 10th April she was lying peacefully in Narvik harbour with other merchant ships and some German Destroyers, when the British Destroyers Hardy, Hunter, and Havelock swept into the harbour and tried to sink everything in sight. They completely surprised the Germans, sinking two of their destroyers and severely crippling others. They also shot up and sunk a number of merchant ships, and put a torpedo into the Romanby. The ship sank quite quickly, and now rests upright, with her keel in around 30 meters.

The Steamship Romanby.

The Steamship Romanby.

This was a great dive. At first we went inside the engine room which was like a huge cavern and chock full of great big valves. Many of the engine room gangways were still intact which helped to give some scale to the area, because for me, what made this dive was the sheer size of the engine room. As we went towards the bow, we came up to the compartments on the deck. In here were loads of portholes. They were opaque looking and had a lovely green glass that you could still look out through.

The Rudder and prop shaft. (Photo F. Bang)

The Rudder and prop shaft. (Photo F. Bang)

In the area where we dropped, were winches, and a huge mass of broken metal and other debris. Back in some other compartments, what was really great were the amount of cables hanging down from the deck heads. It made the whole area spooky and atmospheric, as you slowly swam through, brushing past the cables like the cobwebs that you would brush away in an old forgotten house. The whole wreck had shoals of small fish, and large horse mussels encrusted the metal plates. This was a feature seen on most of the other wrecks. There were also some very large anemones and huge starfish. In one great bit of the engine room near the prop shaft, which was huge, was a rope hanging down with a mass of tube fans hanging off it. Brilliant. Viz 25 ft.

In the Corridor. (Photo F. Bang)

In the Corridor. (Photo F. Bang)

Second Dive. Wind howling, can’t do the 3 destroyers, so back to the Romanby. Completely different dive to last time. Saw the rudder and then stayed at about 60 ft going through all the cabins and passages. Really nice. Lots of portholes, found a bit of a square one. We also went into another part of the engine room. Big holds and long passages to swim down. Nice.

Dead mens fingers. (Photo F. Bang)

Dead mens fingers. (Photo F. Bang)

Narvik overview

The period between the outbreak of the Second World War and the invasion of Norway is often called the Phoney war. Whilst on land this might have been the case, with the opposing army’s glowering at each other from either side of the Western Front, at sea it was an entirely different matter. Over 400 allied merchant ships had already been sunk, and the Royal Oak, the aircraft carrier Courageous, six destroyers and three submarines had all been lost. The Germans hadn’t come through unscathed either, losing amongst others seventeen U-boats, and the mighty Battleship Graff Spee.

The destruction of the mighty Graf Spee.

The destruction of the mighty Graf Spee.

So why invade Norway? Germany’s entire war production rested on the iron ore that she got from Sweden. However in the winter the Baltic ports froze solid, so the ore had to be transported by rail to Narvik in Norway which was ice free, and then shipped to Germany through protected neutral waters behind the chain of Norwegian islands. Something had to be done about this and Churchill, by now First Lord of the Admiralty, was all for occupying Norway as soon as possible. But for the politicians, this was fraught with danger. In the first place Churchill’s enemies kept harping back to his fiasco in the Dardanelle’s in the First War, and secondly, the Government felt that an occupation could only take place with the ascent of the king of Norway, as an outright attack on a friendly nation was not considered politically practical. In the end a decision of sorts was made to lay mines in Norwegian waters.

Map showing both Fleet's approach to Narvik.

Map showing both Fleet’s approach to Narvik.

This it was hoped would drive the ore ships out of territorial waters where they could be seized by the British. It was fairly obvious that the Germans would react badly to this, so an expeditionary force was proposed just in case the Germans did decide to land in Norway. It was all to little to late because the Germans had already come to the same conclusions as Churchill, and they had also got wind of the British intention to mine the entrances to the fjords. In order to protect their source of iron ore, and not be forestalled by the British, they secretly planned their own invasion of Narvik. The operation was called ‘Wesserubung’ and it called for troops to be landed by ship simultaneously in the early hours of April 9th at Narvik, Trondheim, Bergen, Kristiansond and Oslo.

Kommodore Fredrich Bonte.

Kommodore Fredrich Bonte.

Ten destroyers under the command of Kommodore Fredrich Bonte comprised Group One of the invasion force bound for Narvik. Bonte had assembled his force at the north German port of Breverhaven, some 1020 miles from Narvik, and since surprise was essential it was decided to sail early on the 7th April and steam at 20 knots to the entrance of Vestifjord escorted by the battle cruisers Scharnhorst ,Gneisau and the Hipper, who was also carrying 1700 troops. The U-boat arm was ordered to support the operation with every available boat, and amongst those commanders present was the famous ace Gunter Prien, already showered with honours for the destruction of the Royal Oak.

The Battleship Gneisenau, which had nine 11 inch guns.

The Battleship Gneisenau, which had nine 11 inch guns.

At the same time as all this was happening, oblivious to what was going on, the British started their own, Operation Wilfred. This was to lay mines on the morning of April 8th off the outer shore of Vestfjord, and near Statlandet, with a dummy minefield off Bud Among the assembled Fleet were two Destroyer groups, Minelayers, and the Battle cruisers Renown, Repulse and Warspite So it was, that by pure coincidence, both fleets were at sea in the same area, but didn’t know it. Also, the British had not yet realized the Germans true intensions as previous intelligence on the subject had been either discounted or ignored.

Mountain troops embarking on the Battleship Hipper.

Mountain troops embarking on the Battleship Hipper.

All that changed when H.M.S. Gloworm lost a man overboard in atrocious weather and turned back to try and find him. She ran slap into three German destroyers, who because of the heavy weather had got detached from their taskforce. She immediately opened fire on all three and sent off signals to alert the Fleet. The Gloworm didn’t have much chance of hitting anything as the sea’s were just too ferocious to provide a decent gun platform, and any way the German destroyers were more in danger from each other as they tried to take avoiding action.

The Gloworm as seen from the Bridge of the Battleship Hipper.

The Gloworm as seen from the Bridge of the Battleship Hipper.

Meanwhile the Battle Cruiser Hipper arrived on the scene and proceeded to pound the Gloworm to pieces with 8 inch shells. In desperation the Skipper Lt. Roope fired his torpedos but missed as the Hipper dodged behind a smoke screen. However when the Hipper re-emerged from the smoke, she found the Gloworm closing at full speed. The ship smashed into the side of the Hipper, and all of a sudden her guns went quiet.The Hipper was severely damaged, but still managed to save the survivors from the Gloworm, 38 in all. Sadly the Captain was not among them. He was later awarded the V.C. posthumously.

Lt. Commander Gerald Broadmead Roope.

Lt. Commander Gerald Broadmead Roope.

In an interesting development after Germany surrendered, the Hipper was found stranded at Kiel, and a plaque was found on one of her forward gun mountings. It read:

“At thjs gun fell Ord. Gunner Josef Ritter. Died for his fatherland on 8.4 .4?when engaging the British destroyer .’Glowworm.’ “

In the event the German Fleet evaded the British Fleet in the storm, and Bonte’s Group One, ended up positioned off the Norwegian coast during the daylight of 8th April. The Force entered Ofotfjord shortly after 4 am the next morning, sinking two ancient Norwegian warships, the Norge and the Eidsvold. The Commandant of the Norwegian Garrisson, Colonel Sundlo, who was German friendly, quickly surrendered, and one hour later Narvik was firmly in German hands.

The ancient battleships Norge and Eisfold.

The ancient battleships Norge and Eisfold.

Meanwhile the Admiralty was still unaware of how many destroyers were in Narvik, sent a signal to Warberton- Lee in command of the Second Destroyer Group, saying that a German ship had landed a small force at Narvik. Warburton-Lee wasn’t convinced by this intelligence, so landed a party at the Pilot Station at Vestfjord to find out what was happening. When he realizes the true state of affairs he decided to launch a dawn attack.

Colonel Sudlo.

Colonel Sudlo.

At half past four that morning, it was snowing heavily, reducing visibility to less than a thousand yards. Leaving Hostile and Hotspur guarding the outer entrance, Warburton-Lee in Hardy, together with Hunter and Havalock swept into Narvik harbour sinking two destroyers ( Kommodore Bonte was killed in this attack)and damaging at least three others, whilst at the same time sinking several merchant ships. An hour later the British withdrew under cover of smoke, but ran straight into the remaining five German destroyers who sank Hardy and Hunter and severely damaged Hotspur. The remaining German destroyers that had so far escaped damage, retired into the shelter of the Fjords but now faced a real problem. Most of their ammunition had been used up and they were desperately short of fuel, so much so that they risked being permanently trapped in the Fjords. The rest of the British Fleet had now arrived, including the Battleship Warspite and the Aircraft Carrier Glorious, and so now had the advantage of overwhelming force. Quite why they waited three days to finish the job is unclear, but finish the job they did, sinking the rest of the German destroyers in a bloody, hard fought battle, in which the Germans fought down to the last shell.

Narvik, Dickens

Narvik, Dickens

The Battles of Narvik and their causes are complex. I have drawn heavily on these two excellent books for information and understanding. Any mistakes, as ever, are mine, not theirs.

The Narvik Campaign, Johan Waage

The Narvik Campaign, Johan Waage

Today the two battles are commemorated by a Narvik Association, which holds an annual meeting of the survivors from both sides. The British did occupy parts of Norway, but with the German invasion of Belgium, the Netherlands and France, and the collapse of the Allies in this theatre of war, they had to evacuate, and on 24th May, the British reluctantly abandoned Norway to its fate.

Martha Henrik Fisser

The Martha Henrik Fisser was originally the British Steamship, Blackheath, and was built at Stockton in 1911.

Martha Henrik Fisser.

Martha Henrik Fisser.

On the 9th of April 1940 she lay in Narvik harbour after loading a cargo of iron ore for onward transit to Germany.However when the newly arrived German forces arrived on that day, she was stopped from sailing, and ordered to remain inside the harbour area. The next day the British Destroyers lead by H.M.S. Hardy, steamed into the harbour and laid waste to all the shipping therein. The Martha Henrik Fisser stopped a torpedo right in the early stages of the battle, and quickly sank quite near to the wreck of the Strassa.

Spare prop. (Photo F. Bang)

Spare prop. (Photo F. Bang)

This is a really nice dive but it has to be a long one as ou have to go down on the Strasser, swim along to near its stern, then off on a rope to the MHF. You have to do it this way because you are not allowed to surface or descend in the shipping channel. However it’s a great dive and well worth the long swim.

The aftermath of the British attack.

The aftermath of the British attack.

We went straight into the engine rooms, which were fantastic. All that engine room staging and staircases, and some great big pipes going right down into this huge cavern. Probably the pipes were for the iron ore. The light was going so we swam up to the bow and swam through some of the deck passages, got lost and had trouble finding the rope that connected the MHF to the Strassa.

The light's going. (Photo F. Bang)

The light’s going. (Photo F. Bang)

Once we had sorted which was our left hand, we had no trouble locating the rope and off we went back to the Strassa, and on up to the surface. Nice Dive. Once again just a skim, but it will stay in the memory.

Karmoy

The Karmoy was built in Alloa (Scotland) in 1921 and was around 295 feet long with a beam of 43 feet. After the German invasion of Norway, she was requisitioned by the Germans and used as a general gargo transporter between Germany and Norway. On the 28th of October 1940 she was sunk outside Lodigen by aircraft from the British Carrier Implacable.

Karmoy.

Karmoy.

On this dive we anchored into the stern where there is the remains of a ships wheel. that was quite a sight, even though its worn away quite a bit.Over the stern down towards the bottom, is the rudder and the bronze shank where the prop was. There is a whole tangle of stuff at the stern, and after I had a good poke around there I went briefly into the holds. Inside the stern are rows of iron portholes with brass butterfly nuts. Uptop heading towards the bow, there were lots of railings, davits, and some nice wooded stairs leading up to the deck. I got to the bows first, so had it to myself. It looked really good with shoals of small fish all over it. There are lots of jelly fish some small, others huge with long trailing tentacles that could give a nasty sting. You get the same sort in Scotland.Nice dive, but once again not long enough.

Z19 Herman Kunne

The Herman Kunne, together with the Hans Luderman, Wilhelm Heidcamp, Dieter von Roeder,and Anton Schmitt were all Dieter Von Roeder class destroyers. They had a displacement of 2400 tons and a complement of 313 officers and men. They were 384 feet long, 38 ?feet in the beam with a draught of 9 ?feet. The Destroyers were powered by two shaft geared turbines with six boilers producing a total of 70,000 horsepower which gave a top speed of around 38 knots.

Z19 Herman Kunne.

Z19 Herman Kunne.

Their armament was impressive consisting of five 5inch guns all in single, hand worked mountings, which fired ten rounds per gun per minute. In addition she had six 3.7 cm automatic aircraft guns in two twin, and two single mountings and twelve 20mm guns in five twin and two single mountings. As well as all this the destroyers also carried eight 21 inch Mark G7A torpedo’s in quad mountings. The only fly in the ointment was the fact that the 5 inch guns only had 100 rounds a gun, and that in the end, more than anything else, sealed their fate.

At four thirty on the morning of 10th April 1940 the German Destroyers Herman Kunne and Hans Luderman lay alongside the fuel tanker Jan Wellam, and were both in the process of refuelling. Nearby in the harbour were also anchored the Destroyers Dieter Von Roeder, Anton Schmitt, and the Willhelm Heidkamp, along with about twenty five other cargo ships. It was snowing hard and visibility was down to under a thousand yards. It was then that the British Destroyers struck, sweeping into the harbour sinking the Anton Schmitt and Willhelm Heidcamp. There was total confusion amongst the Germans who at first thought that they were under air attack. As the British turned around in the Beisfjord, the Dieter Von Roeder was hit and caught fire. The Herman Kunne was not actually hit in these exchanges but suffered some engine damage as a result of the shock waves from the explosions in the harbour.

Wilhelm Heidkamp slowly sinking.

Wilhelm Heidkamp slowly sinking.

When the British withdrew, the Germans had a chance to regroup their forces, refuel some of their ships, and realize that they were running disastrously short of ammunition. Commodore Bonte had been killed in his Flagship, Willhelm Heidcamp in the first attack, and so Captain Bey took over. He only had three undamaged destroyers left, with only half their ammunition, and virtually no fuel. His four other ships had fuel, but were extremely badly damaged. While he was trying to sort out his problems, Captain Bey was ordered to return with his group to Germany. He hesitated to obey, because with the light spring nights it was almost impossible to sneak out of Vestfjorden without the British spotting him. In the end he judged the risk to be too great, which was unfortunate for him, because at 10 o’clock on April 13th he received reports that the British were steaming into Ofotjorden. The Second Battle of Narvik was about to begin.

Fregattenkapitan Erich Bey, Senior Officer 4th Destroyer Flotilla. Survived the Narvik campaign only to be lost when serving on the Battleship Scharnhorst.

Fregattenkapitan Erich Bey, Senior Officer 4th Destroyer Flotilla. Survived the Narvik campaign only to be lost when serving on the Battleship Scharnhorst.

To better organize his forces, Captain Bey decided to sacrifice the Erich Kollner, which was very badly damaged. He turned her into a floating gun battery, taking off most of the crew and only leaving enough men to man the guns. She then limped out to Tarstad with orders to engage the British Fleet when they appeared. The Herman Kunne followed her out to Tjeldbotn. An hour later, a Swordfish Aircraft from the Battleship Warspite was spotted by the Herman Kunne, with the result that the British lost the element of surprise. In the event it didn’t matter much. The Warspite pulverized the Erich Koellner and sunk her. The Herman Kunne was badly damaged, but managed to retire behind a smoke screen to Narvik.

The Swordfish, obolete when the War started, was still very effective.

The Swordfish, obolete when the War started, was still very effective.

In the harbour the rest of the German Destroyers came out of the harbour to face the British who were steaming towards them. For over an hour the battle raged without either side really making any impression. The Germans however were in real trouble because nearly all their ammunition had been used up in the fierce fire fight, so Captain Bey ordered then to withdraw to Rombaken. The Herman Kunne, never received that order and sailed into the Herjangsfjord with the British Destroyers Eskimo and Forrester in pursuit. Out of ammunition, Korvettenkapitan Koethe decided to beach his ship, land his crew and then scuttle the ship.

Right at the stern. Photo F. Bang

Right at the stern. Photo F. Bang

He drove the vessel ashore at Trollvika, Herjangsfjord at ten past two in the afternoon. All the crew managed to scramble ashore which was just as well, because ten minutes later Eskimo and Forrester fired three torpedo’s,into the Herman Kunne which caused an enormous explosion and set the Herman Kunne on fire. As the smoke from her funeral pyre darkened the sky she finally slid beneath the waves.

Stern showing prop shaft and rudder.

Stern showing prop shaft and rudder.

This wreck was stuck down the side of the Fjord. Bow in 2 ft, stern in 40 meters. We went down to 119 ft. We had been told we would have great viz, but in fact needed a torch.However this is another vast wreck just like the G.T. lying on its side, but no guns.Down at the stern are the remains of the rails used for minelaying. There is loads of stuff in the debris field like leather thigh seaboots, leather ammo pouches, a deadlight, shoes, and some uniforms, just to give you a flavour.

Stern showing mine rails. Photo F Bang.

Stern showing mine rails. Photo F Bang.

From 60 ft up to the surface the wreck is one vast jumble of twisted metal with loads of small fish and some large cod. You could spend ages going trough it all and it is very scenic. Some of the guys spent time unfolding uniforms, and others just wandering around looking. i spent nearly an hour here and frankly could have spent days. Always the same, to little time. great dive, and a great atmospheric wreck.

H.M.S.Hardy

H.M.S.Hardy's Ensign on show at H.M.S.Raleigh training base, Torpoint Cornwall.

H.M.S.Hardy’s Ensign on show at H.M.S.Raleigh training base, Torpoint Cornwall.

photo courtesy Warrant Officer Anthony Royle, who is the Grandson of Cyril Cope

H.M.S.Hardy was completed in 1936. She was 337 feet long, 34 feet in the beam, with a draft of nearly nine feet. She was powered by two shaft geared turbines linked to three boilers, and could reach speeds in excess of thirty knots. For armament she carried five 4.7 inch Mk1X quick firing guns in single mountings, eight 0.5 inch anti aircraft guns in twin mountings, and eight Mark 1X torpedoes in quad mountings. Her complement was supposed to be 175 officers and men, but at the time of the battle she was probably carrying more than that.

The Jane R. over the wreck of H.M.S.Hardy. Photo Frank Beng.

The Jane R. over the wreck of H.M.S.Hardy. Photo Frank Beng.

On the morning of April 8th 1940, the British mounted Operation Wilfred, who’s main purpose was to lay mines of the southern side of Vestfjord, together with a dummy minefield off Bud. Besides the Battleships Renown and Warspite, and the Carrier Courageous, the minelayers were to be escorted by the Second Destroyer Flotilla under the command of Captain (D) Bernard A.W. Warburton-Lee, in H.M.S.Hardy. Whilst the British were mounting ‘Wilfred’, the Germans had started Operation Weserbung, with the intention of occupying Norway. Thus, unknowingly, both Fleets were due to be in the same bit of sea at the same time. In howling gales and snowstorms, elements of both sides spotted each other and briefly engaged, only to loose contact in the atrocious weather.

HMS Hardy

HMS Hardy

Neither side really knew what was going on, especially the British, but the brief encounter caused a flurry of signals back to the Admiralty. They knew nothing about the events that were about to happen in Narvik, but had already had reports about German warships approaching Oslo, Trodheim, Bergan and Stavanger. The Admiralty immediately issued orders for the task Force to keep watch on Narvik and report any developments. At 1200 hours on April 9th Captain Warbuton -Lee was in the Vestfjord when he received a signal from the Admiralty telling him that some troops had landed at Narvik, and ordered him to seizee or sink their transport ships, and if he thought prudent, recapture the Town.

Capt. Bernard A.W. Warburton-Lee

Capt. Bernard A.W. Warburton-Lee

Warburton-Lee, or ‘Wash’, as he was known to his crew, was a bit of a ‘press on’ character, and relished this new challenge. He decided to sail for Narvik with five Destroyers, Hardy, Havelock, Hostile, Hunter and Hotspur. But before he fully committed himself he wanted to find out a bit more about what was going on. So at 1600 hours he stopped at Tranoy and sent two officers ashore to the Pilot Station to ask around. Even though there were some difficulties with the language, it transpired that at least six warships and a U-boat had passed the Station on their way to Narvik. ‘Wash’ passed all this information to the Admiralty and informed them of his intention to attack the next day at high tide.

Capt. Warburton-Lee's Uniform.

Capt. Warburton-Lee’s Uniform.

On April 10th 1940, at 4-30 in the morning, Hardy, Hunter, and Havelock steamed into the harbour at Narvik leaving Hostile and Hotspur to guard the back door. Arriving inside the harbour, Warburton-Lee immediately torpedoed the Wilhelm Heidkamp, the flagship of Kommodore Bonte, Senior Officer Narvik Destroyer Force. The stern was blown into the air, killing Bonte and eighty of his men. Next to go was the Anton Schmitt, which was torpedoed and sunk with the loss of sixty three men. In the ensuing battle the Dieter Von Roeder launched eight torpedoes, none of which scored a hit, but she sustained many hits herself, and later caught fire, as did the Hans Luderman. Whilst all this was going on the Hotspur, which had been guarding the harbour entrance, came alone into the harbour and torpedoed two merchant ships.

Wilhelm Heidkamp slowly sinking.

Wilhelm Heidkamp slowly sinking.

Since no German warships had been seen outside the harbour, Warburton-Lee thought he had all the Germans in the bag, (he didn’t realise that there were another five Destroyers nearby) so he turned his vessels at high speed and came back into the harbour to have another go at the merchant ships, blazing away with his guns, sinking and damaging six vessels. Up to now he had been incredibly lucky with only Hotspur suffering any hits, but as Warburton-Lee gathered his forces to depart his luck started to change for the worse.

Dieter Von Roeder

Dieter Von Roeder

The British Destroyers laid down a thick smoke screen to hide their departure, but as they headed out across the Fjord they ran into the five other German Destroyers as they charged into the Ofotfjord. The Georg Thiele and Bernard Von Armin came from Ballanger, and the Erich Giese, Erick Koellner and the Wolfgan Zenker sailed in from the Herjangfjord, surrounding the British Force in a pincer movement. In a fierce battle the five German Destroyers fought the five British Derstroyers with sustained and rapid gunfire. Most of the German gunfire targeted the British Flagship Hardy, which came under fire from two ships, most notably the George Thiele. The Hardy sustained several direct hits and soon burst into flames. When the bridge took a direct hit, Warburton-Lee was severely injured, but before he collapsed he ordered his Flotilla to ‘keep on engaging the enemy’.

Churchill inspecting the' Hardy' Survivors at Horseguards Parade, see film below for more.

Churchill inspecting the’ Hardy’ Survivors at Horseguards Parade, see film below for more.

HMS HARDY’S MEN IN LONDON

Other than Warburton-Lee, nearly everbody on the bridge had been killed except for Paymaster Lt. Geoffrey Standing, the Captain’s Secertary. He awoke from the fearful blast to find his foot wounded, the ship out of control and heading for the shore at thirty knots. Since the wheel house was below him and nobody was answering his increasingly desperate orders to put the wheel over, he managed to hop down a ladder to the wheel house and alter course, enough to stop hitting the shore. When he regained the bridge helped by some seamen, he saw that they were now heading for two German destroyers. Since he could not slow down he decided to ram one of them. Luckily for all those left alive on board, whilst he was deciding which one to have a go at, one of the boilers was hit and the engines ground to a halt.

The wreckage of the Hardy. Note the shell in this left hand photo.

The wreckage of the Hardy. Note the shell in this left hand photo.
The wreckage of the Hardy. Note the shell in the left hand photo.

The wreckage of the Hardy. Note the shell in the left hand photo.
H.M.S. Hardy aground.

H.M.S. Hardy aground.

All the front guns on the Hardy were by now inoperable, but one of the stern guns was still banging away at the Germans who naturally returned fire into the burning wreck. Luckily the Hardy still had some ‘way’ on her which allowed Stanning to manoeuvre her into Vidrek where she ran aground. As she glided ashore still blazing furiously Stanning gave the order to abandon ship. One hundred and forty men plunged into the icy water, and in between the shell bursts from the German Destroyers, managed to clamber to safety on the shore. Warburton-Lee was still just alive when they got him ashore but died an hour later. The wreck of the Hardy lay burning until it lifted of the shore at high tide and drifted over to Skjomes where the vessel finally capsized.

Paymaster Lt. G. Stanning.

Paymaster Lt. G. Stanning.

Photo Rosemary Barnes, his daughter

Warburton-Lee was later awarded the Victoria Cross, the first posthumous V.C. to be awarded in the Second World War.

One of the many casualities.

One of the many casualities.

Probably the most famous of the British Destroyers in the battles of Narvik, Hardy is now just a huge debris field right close into shore. It is not really a dive, more a rummage, and you could do with a lot more time than the half hour allotted to us. Still, found a porthole, a gas mask, and many small cartidge cases.The wreck’s history gives the place a certain aura, and I for one, was glad to visit her last resting place.

Visit H.M.S Hardy’s last resting place
On the 75th Anniversary of the Battle of Narvik, author Ron Cope shines a spotlight onto the brave young sailors behind this dramatic military campaign, including his father.

_INSERT_CAPTION_

_INSERT_CAPTION_

Attack at Dawn: Reliving the First Battle of Narvik in World War Two by Ron Cope (published by Clink Street Publishing RRP £11.99 paperback, RRP £7.99 ebook) is available from 10 April 2015 online from retailers including amazon.co.uk and to order from all good bookstores.RRP £11.99… ISBN:978-1-909477-97-1 Ebook : 978-1-909477-98-8.

Z13 Erich Koellner

The Erich Koellner was a Leberect Maass Class Destroyer with a displacement of 2200 tons, and a complement of 315 officers and men. She was 374 feet long, 37 feet in the beam, and had a draught of nine and ahalf feet. Her machinery, performance, and armament was similar to the Dieter Von Roeder Class, except that she had four 3.7cm and six 20mm guns.

Launched on the 18th May 1937 the Erich Koellner, Z13, was completed on 8th August 1939. She then conducted offensive mining operations around the North Sea. She was not a lucky ship and in February 1940 she was involved in a bizarre incident, when in company with other destroyers she attacked elements of the British Fishing Fleet in the North Sea. In the midst of the engagement a German aircraft came along and happily bombed the hell out of the German Destroyers who fled in panic into a previously unknown British minefield. Two Destroyers, Z1 and Z3 were sunk, and the Erich Koellner, in an effort to rescue some of their stricken crews, managed to drown some of her own whilst launching the rescue boat. The Skipper then thought he saw torpedo tracks so abandoned the rest of the sailors in his attempt to escape, almost ramming the wreckage of the Z1, which he mistook for a submarines conning tower.

It must have come as some relief for the Z13’s Skipper, Korvette Kapitain Schulze-Hinrichs, when on the 7th April 1940 he became part of Group 1, (Narvik). He embarked two hundred troops at Wesermunde, and after meeting up with the taskforce lead by the Battleship Hipper, the Z13 arrived at Narvik on the 9th April after an extremely rough passage. She landed her troops at Elvegard at the head of Herjantsfjord where she anchored for the night in company with Z9 and Z12. Just before dawn on the 10th April five British Destroyers, Hardy, Hunter, Hotspur, Hostile, and Havelock slipped past the two U-boats guarding the entrance to Ofotfjord and sailed twenty five miles up the Fjord to completely surprise the Five German Destroyers lying peacefully in Narvik Harbour.

Narvik harbour after the first Battle.

Narvik harbour after the first Battle.

Two German Destroyers were sunk at once and three were fatally crippled. The British only suffered a minor hit and were gleefully withdrawing when Z13, Z9 and Z12 emerged from Herjangsfjord and surprised them. In the fight that followed (First battle of Narvik) the British were caught in a crossfire as two other German Destroyers, Z2 and Z11 charged out of Ballangenfjord. A running battle soon developed and the Hardy was blasted by gunfire and forced aground. Soon Hunter was hard hit and to make matters worse was rammed by Hotspur who had been badly damaged by gunfire. Hotspur managed to untangle herself, but Hunter could not be saved and sank.

H.M.S. Hunter seen here at Plymouth before the Battle.

H.M.S. Hunter seen here at Plymouth before the Battle.

As the British escaped, the Erich Koellner and the two other German Destroyers briefly gave chase but soon broke of the engagement.This proved to be unfortunate for the Germans as the British came across the Ammunition ship Rauenfels loaded to the gunnels with desperately needed 5 inch shells. She was literally blown to pieces, and her remains can still be seen scattered all over (and I mean all over) the nearby hills.

You can just see some wreckage from the Rauenfels on the hills at the bottom of the tree line.

You can just see some wreckage from the Rauenfels on the hills at the bottom of the tree line.

On the 11th April Z13 was fully operational and was one of the few ships that had managed to refuel. As she was moved to her dispersal point in Ballengenfjord, the Skipper misjudged the depth, ran aground, ripped open her bottom flooding No 2 and 3 boiler rooms, her torpedo warhead room and her transmitting area. Although she effectively carried out damage control and managed to stay afloat, she was by now only fit to be used as a floating gun battery. By the time of the Second Battle of Narvik two days later, the Z13 was in the process of being escorted to Taarstadt by Z19 where she was to lay in ambush for the next expected British attack. Soon reports reached her that the British Force was already steaming down the Fjord. Z19 went ahead to asses the situation, leaving the Z13 to make her way to Djupvik in the hope of still being able to effect an ambush.

The Erich Koellner hit for the first time.

The Erich Koellner hit for the first time.

Unfortunately for her spotter planes from the Battleship Warspite reported her position, and the Tribal Class Destroyers, Bedouin and Eskimo were sent around the point north of Djupvik where they engaged the Z13 at a range of three and a half thousand yards. Unable to manoeuvre, the Z13 was an easy target. She was hit in her boilers and turbine room, and then a torpedo blew her bows off. To finish her off, Warspite came up and pounded her with two salvoes forcing her Captain to scuttle her to save needless loss of life. Even so thirty one men were killed and many more wounded.

Warspite completing the Erich Koellner's destruction.

Warspite completing the Erich Koellner’s destruction.

After the War the Erich Koellner was heavily salvaged and today all that is left is a huge pile of scrap, most of which is in about sixty ft of water.However just about everthing that is brass is here, especially valve chests by the ton. the real oddity however is the amount of uniform clothing that is still lying around. Jackets, shirts and some pullovers are to be found and other items are leather seaboots and shoes.There is loads of metal to pick over, and it is a great ‘grot’ dive, which would be even better if you were allowed a hammer. ( all right, I give in.) One thing I hadn’t seen before, was a shell hoist with the brass checks intact, and a round still in place. I only had about fifty mins on this wreck, so only managed to skim it. Shame.

The Warspite opens fire.

The Warspite opens fire.

Dornier 26 DO Seaplane

The Dornier 26 DO Seaplane was designed for transatlantic service and was used extensively as a reconnaissance plane in the Norwegian Campaign.

Donier Seaplane

Donier Seaplane

She had four tandem engines and retractable pontoons. Quite when she was shot down is unclear, but probably in the Second Battle of Narvik.

Fuselarge. Photo F. Bang

Fuselarge. Photo F. Bang

This was a really nice dive, made even more so as this is probably the only one in the world underwater. Tailplane, wings, fuserlarge.

Tail. (Photo F. Bang)

Tail. (Photo F. Bang)

Recognisable as a plane. Even the ailerons work.To many off us on it, but its only about 20 meters from the shore so the skipper gets a bit fraught. Viz 20ft

Prop on one of the engines. (Photo F. Bang)

Prop on one of the engines. (Photo F. Bang)

Blackwatch

The motorvessel Black Watch was, in her time, one of the most modern vessels in her class. She was built for the Fred Olsen Lines in 1939 and was designed to serve as a passenger ship between Kristiansand, Newcastle and Oslo. However after the German occupation of Norway she was requisitioned by the German Kriegsmarine, and so only had time for just a few trips before the war broke out.

The Blackwatch in happier times.

The Blackwatch in happier times.

The Black Watch had a Norwegian crew until 1943, when the Germans decided to put their own crew on board. From 1943 she was used as a headquarters by the German General Der Infanterie E. Dietl, and as a depot and recreation ship for the German submarine crews . On the afternoon of the 4th of May 1945, Black Watch was quietly lying at anchor in Kilbotnbukta in company with the German submarine U 711, when they were both attacked by British Avenger and Wildcat airplanes. Dropping bombs and firing machine cannons, the British airplanes straffed the Black Watch and U 711 and inflicted heavy damage on both of them. The British pilots said that they scored seven direct hits before the Blackwatch suddenly exploded and broke in two, sinking shortly afterwards. In the one sided engagement the U 711 was also sunk, and lies some five hundred yards away from the wreck of the Blackwatch.

The funeral pyre of the Blackwatch.

The funeral pyre of the Blackwatch.

This is a huge wreck very close in to the shore. Its bow is only in about 40 ft and the rest goes down to around 150 ft with a heavy list to port. Most of the stern was heavily salvaged but that doesn’t really matter because there is an awful lot of her left. On the shore are some small wooden cabins, so if you had one you would have a wreck right at the bottom of your garden.

The Decent. (photo F.Bang)

The Decent. (photo F.Bang)

We dropped about midships near the bridge which still had some of the teak on its deck and were plensantly surprised at the near 40ft visibility. We swam over the side and down into a great big hole, and then went into another large hole just off that, down a deck, then down another into a huge cavern. This was really impressive, it was one of the biggest spaces I have ever been in. Back up top is a huge jumble of metal that you could spend hours going through, but go on to the Bridge deck where the square windows are still in place. The fish life was quite good, loads of scallops, an Atlantic Halibut, and also a sort of compressed ling with yellow markings, called a brother.

Somewhere near the bridge, I think .(Photo F.Bang)

Somewhere near the bridge, I think .(Photo F.Bang)

On the second dive went down to the bow. Loads of portholes on the way, but also two huge doors with portholes. Inside their compartments were what looked like generators. There was a huge cavern lying as it were on its side, still with an all wood floor, and the general consensus was that this might have been the Ballroom or maybe a restaurant. You could see the different decks this time as you had your eye in and started to get some idea of the layout. The bow is well broken up and all I saw of note was some bollards. This wreck was voted the second best dive that we did, but as always you only skim the surface with a couple of dives, and we are all thinking about coming back and renting one of those wooden cabins.

This wreck is just huge. (Photo F.Bang)

This wreck is just huge. (Photo F.Bang)

500 meters away is supposed to be the wreck of the sub U711 which was sunk in the same attack, but at the moment nobody is allowed to dive it.

Volnay

The Devon and Cornwall coast is almost as infamous for its spine chilling tales of wreckers, as it is famous for its shipwrecks. Even today the wrecking tradition lives on, as the owners of the ill fated Johanna, wrecked earlier this year at Hartland Point, found out to their cost. Within hours of that unfortunate ship crashing ashore she was stripped of virtually everything, including the radar scanner.

Sometimes however, a ship sinks and instead of the wreckers getting the cargo, nature takes a hand and presents the local community with an unexpected bonanza. Such an incident happened at Porthallow near Falmouth on December 1917, and it involved the British steamer Volnay.

The Volnay was a ship of some 4610 tons owned by Gow Harrison and Company. She was homeward bound from Canada, and part of her cargo consisted of much needed ammunition for the troops fighting the Great War in France. The other part of the cargo however, was to be of much more interest to the inhabitants of Porthallow as it contained items of food such as coffee, sugar, butter, jam, and potato crisps, which after two years of war had become almost unobtainable.

When the Volnay arrived off the Manacles there was an explosion by her bows, and her Captain assumed he had hit a mine. There was no immediate panic, and soon two tugs came out to assist the stricken vessel into Porthallow Bay. Unfortunately the Captain had badly underestimated the damage done by the explosion, and instead of trying to beach his ship he left it in the middle of the Bay where it promptly sank, spilling some of its cargo.

Later in the day a strong onshore wind blew up and soon tons of the Volnays cargo was piling ashore. In fact so much came ashore that it was almost impossible to see the beach, and in places the boxes and sacks were piled nearly five feet high. For days afterwards no boats could be launched to get out to the wreck. Not because of the bad weather, but simply because there was just no room to pull the boats down to the sea. That Christmas of 1917 must have been the best in living memory.

Today the Volnay lies in nearly 70 feet of water on a sandy bottom. Although the wreck is well broken up, there are still some very large pieces, but the whole site is covered in a fine layer of silty sand and you must be careful not to stir things up. I first dived on the Volnay in April of 1982,and this is what I wrote in my log book then.

The marks that I had put me right near the two massive boilers, which with their light coating of deadmens fingers, provide a good home for some very fine spotted wrasse.

All around the boilers are scattered large amounts of wreckage, including bollards, winches, chain, and a lot of wooden ammunition boxes. Further out from the boilers lie large areas of broken deck plates and rib sections all jumbled one on top of the other. It is extremely difficult to match up bits of the wreck with their relative positions, but with visibility averaging 25 feet you can have a lot of fun trying.

Most of the ammunition from the Volnay was salvaged, but as the wreck broke up over the years more came to light. Nearly all the ammunition is 18 pdr Shrapnel. All of it is fused, live, and very badly corroded, so force yourself to leave it well alone. Incidentally, the shrapnel container is made of light steel, and often this has completely disintegrated causing the brass nose fuse to drop off. Many of these lie scattered in the sand and obviously some must have been taken for souvenirs, because they are very attractive and look harmless.

Unfortunately these nosecones contain two detonators, so if you have one on your mantelpiece, take care. Because of the Volnay’s fairly shallow depth, you can have a nice long dive on her. This is just as well because she is a very picturesque wreck, ideal for photographers and there is a lot of her to explore. All of us who dived on the Volnay that day were very impressed, and I for one will be making a return visit.

Since those early days I have dived the Volnay several times and mostly been disappointed as the sand cover seemed to increase, making it difficult for me to get my bearings. Hover on my last dive in 2001 all was as I remembered on my first dive. The sand has receded and the wreck now sticks up in great chunks. A local dive school has a small buoy on the wreck, so it is easy to find.

There are not many bits of ammo left but a few of the wooden boxes can still be found. All in all a good dive.

Bay of Panama

Built by the Belfast shipping firm of Hartland and Wolff in 1883, the Bay of Panama was described by everyone who saw her as probably the finest sailing ship afloat. With her steel hull, and four square-rigged masts, she was a very fast and beautiful ship of 2282 tons. But strength and good looks are no guarantee, and during March 1891 the Bay of Panama met up with the worst blizzard Cornwall had suffered for over two hundred years. It was to prove no contest. Because of her speed, the Bay of Panama was used on the Calcutta run, and on November 18th 1890 she left that port bound for Dundee loaded with a cargo of 13000 bales of jute.

For four months she sailed swiftly towards England until one morning during the early part of March 1891, she approached the Cornish coast in rapidly deteriorating weather. The Captain knew all about the dangers of a lee shore, but because of the bad visibility he was uncertain as to his exact position. He could see that the weather was unlikely to get any better, and he even thought that there might be some snow. After weighing up all the risks he decided to heave to, take some depth soundings, and generally take stock of his position. It was a decision that was to cost him his ship, and his life. Only a few hours later, in the early afternoon, a blizzard, the worst for over two centuries, swept into the West Country and engulfed the Bay of Panama.

The wreck of the Bay of Panama.

The wreck of the Bay of Panama.

On board the seamen desperately furled all the sails, and prayed that the ship would ride out the storm. On land, the driving snow and bitter winds produced freezing temperatures the like of which nobody could remember. Sheep and cows were frozen to death in the fields, and at sea many ships came to grief, including four that were wrecked nearby on the Manacles. During that night things became very desperate, and distress flares were fired off. Because of the driving snow nobody saw these, and in the early hours of the following morning, disaster finally struck. A huge wave crashed over the stern, and as it rolled forward it smashed very boat that was lashed on deck. Soon afterwards the Bay of Panama was driven headlong into the cliffs just to the south of Nare Point.

As she struck, she was swung around until her bows pointed eastwards, and then she settled firmly aground with a heavy list to starboard. Some of the topmasts fell down, and shortly afterwards another huge wave broke over the ship, sweeping away the second mate. This wave also completely swamped the main cabin, washing the Captain, his wife and six other crewmen over the side where they all drowned. By now there was pandemonium on deck. Hardly able to see in the driving snow, and soaked by freezing water breaking over the deck, the Mate took charge and ordered everybody into the remaining rigging. Unfortunately for the crew, the freezing spray that showered into the rigging turned quickly into ice, and many of them were frozen to death. During that long period before dawn, many died of exhaustion and cold, and the Ships Bosun, unable to withstand the suffering any longer, went completely mad, and flung himself off the rigging to drown in the tumultuous seas.

Another view of the wreck.

Another view of the wreck.

With the coming of dawn the Bay of Panama presented a truly awful sight. Lying hard and fast under the cliffs, her masts and rigging were in ruins. Her decks contained a shambles of cordage and tattered sails, and over the side there hung a great tangled mess of broken spars, rope, and yet more ruined sails. Even worse was the horrific sight of those men still stuck in the rigging. Some were still feebly clinging to life, but most were by now just frozen corpses. At long last a farmer out looking for his scattered sheep, came across the wreck and quickly summoned help. Soon a breeches buoy was set up, but the seamen still left alive were so weak that they were completely incapable of helping themselves. So the rescuers had to get onboard the wreck and place each man in the harness, and then ferry them ashore. In the end, of the forty people that sailed on the Bay of Panama only seventeen survived.

Joseph Hendy James, who broke the news of the dreadful wreck, on March 9th 1891.

Joseph Hendy James, who broke the news of the dreadful wreck, on March 9th 1891.

However the rescue did not put an end to the hardships that the survivors had to bear. After being fed and unfrozen, the men were put to bed for the night in the village of St.Keverne. The next day, wrapped in blankets they set off for Falmouth in a horse drawn bus. But huge snowdrifts blocked the roads, and soon they could make no more headway. The men were forced to abandon the bus and carry on to Falmouth on foot. Most had no shoes, and nearly all were only clothed in rags and blankets. How they managed to struggle into Falmouth through the snowdrifts and the terrible cold is a story that has long since passed into Cornish legend. The local newspaper, The Falmouth Packet, says it all when it commented that “the men had endured as much privation in that walk as they did in the actual shipwreck”. Those words seem to just about capture the mood of this quite remarkable episode.

dive report to follow

Mohegan

The Mohegan, originally built as the Cleopatra by Earles of Hull, was a vessel of some 7000 tons. Prior to her launching she had been purchased by the Atlantic Transport Company of London on July 29th 1898. The Mohegan was an extremely luxurious and modern ship for her time, and as well as being fitted out in lavish Victorian style, she was also equipped with eight water tight compartments, with a steam pump capable of pumping out each compartment in turn. Measuring 482 feet in length and 52 feet at the beam, the Mohegan drew nearly 20 feet and was capable of a top speed of 14 knots. She carried 97 crew, about 60 first class passengers, and stockmen to attend the animals carried as deck cargo.

The Mohegan from an early watercolour.

The Mohegan from an early watercolour.

The Victorians however were hard taskmasters, and expected value for their money. So when the Mohegans completion was held up by a strike, the builders had to skimp on her specifications and rush her through to avoid the crippling penalty clauses for non-delivery. Her maiden voyage across the Atlantic causes a furore, and she leaked so alarmingly that she had to be docked in New York for repairs before returning to the Tyne for a complete refit. On 13th October 1898 the Mohegan set out on her second voyage. Once again bound for New York, the Mohegan left Tilbury with Captain Griffiths in command. She carried a full complement of 60 passengers and 97 crew, and her general cargo consisted mostly of beer and spirits. However, a fair proportion of the cargo also contained church ornaments and artificial flowers, an odd but faintly prophetic mixture.

The Mohegan's ill fated course.

The Mohegan’s ill fated course.

At first all went well. The weather was quite good, and on the next day, October 14th the Mohegan found herself off Prawle Point, where she made a routine position signal to her owners. Later as she passed Rame Head, she was sighted by a signalman who was surprised to see her less than ten miles offshore. By then the Mohegans fate was almost sealed, because she was already steaming on a compass course that was hopelessly incorrect. At about a quarter to seven that evening, the passengers were just taking their places for dinner. In the first class cabins the nannies were supervising the children’s preparations for bed. On the bridge the lookouts were alert, and in the wheelhouse the helmsman was steering a course ordered by the officer of the watch, and personally checked by the Captain. All was as it should be.

Captain Griffith.

Captain Griffith.

Five minutes later the Mohegan, ablaze with lights smashed at full speed straight into the Manacles Reef, ripping a huge gash right below her waterline. Against this kind of damage the watertight compartments were useless, and several were flooded straight away. Within thirty seconds the engine room had to be abandoned, and very quickly the generators were flooded out plunging the whole ship into complete darkness. On the bridge, Captain Griffiths and his officers managed to fire off some distress rockets and started to get the passengers into the ships boats. However the Mohegans list to port soon became so severe that the starboard lifeboats could not be lowered, and so offered no escape. With threequarters of the ship underwater the Mohegan quickly sank, and within ten minutes of striking she was gone leaving those on deck to swim for their lives. Some managed to cling to the mizzenmasts rigging which remained above the water, but for 106 poor souls their end was at hand.

The Mohegan aground on the Manacles.

The Mohegan aground on the Manacles.

The loss of life would have undoubtedly been even greater but for the presence of mind of the Cox’n of the Porthoustock lifeboat, James Hill. When he saw the Mohegan coming across the bay, he realized that it would most probably hit the Manacles, and he had almost mustered his crew before the Mohegan struck. Two of the luckiest people to survive were a Miss Rondebush, and a Miss Compton-Swift. They had escaped the ship in a lifeboat, which was later overturned, and they were both trapped underneath the boat for over an hour before being rescued. Amongst those who perished were Captain Griffiths and all his officers. Survivors praised all of them for the cool and courageous way they had stemmed the tide of panic, when it became obvious that escape by the ships boats was hopeless.

The mass grave at St.Keverne's Church.

The mass grave at St.Keverne’s Church.

In the aftermath of the disaster an inquiry was held into why the Mohegan had steered such an incorrect course. Many theories were put forward, but since the Captain and all the officers were dead no real conclusion could be reached, and the mystery has remained unanswered to this day. About the only good thing to come out of the disaster were new recommendations into the type of lifesaving equipment to be carried on all passenger ships. Most of the dead were buried in a mass grave at St. Keverne church which more or less overlooks the very spot where the Mohegan struck. Instead of a headstone a simple cross was erected. There was no epitaph, just one word ‘Mohegan’. Three months later the headless corpse of Captain Griffiths was washed ashore in Caernarvon Bay. The sea had finally finished with the Mohegan.

The interment of the victims in the mass grave.

The interment of the victims in the mass grave.

I had always wanted to dive this wreck because it is one of the classic wreck stories. Any wreck with this type of reputation is often over rated, but to my surprise I found the wreck fascinating. I first dived this wreck in 1982 and these were my first impressions.

The day was perfect, with the sea flat calm and the Manacles looking as innocent as apple pie. However the fog started to come down , and only about an hour of slack water we had to get on with the diving fairly quickly.

A plate from the Mohegan displayed at The Five Pilchards Inn.

A plate from the Mohegan displayed at The Five Pilchards Inn.

Incidentally for those who have never been to this part of the country, the Manacles looks like a lunar landscape and casts a brooding air over the whole proceedings.

The remains of the Mohegan are stuck down in between huge pinnacles of rock which are covered in pink and white dead mens fingers. The depth was about seventy feet, with the visibility around twenty feet. There are roughly two different dives on this wreck the first being the Mohegans massive boilers in about eighty five feet and the bow area where I was.

The bows are smashed up but lie on top of the rocks with their ribs stretching away into the distance. A very impressive sight. In amongst the mass of wreckage are the winches that were used to haul up her anchors, and further along were the remains of another boiler, about twenty feet in diameter which was probably used to power the winches. This boiler is extremely picturesque with some of it smashed open to reveal the pipes inside covered with pale pink dead mens fingers.

The steam whistle also at the Inn.

The steam whistle also at the Inn.

After that we sort of just wandered about this huge part of the wreck soaking up the atmosphere. The Wreck has a menacing charm all of it own. The wreck caused great loss of life, and it seems that some how that memory has been entombed with the wreck.

I next dived on the Mohegan in 1990 on the boilers. This time it was early morning and the viz was sixty odd feet. Honest. The boilers were massive and the mass of steel plating stretched into the distance like the M1. Looking up you could see the boat almost impaled by one of the huge rock pinnacle’s. A great dive on a great wreck.

The Manacles – an overview

From Prawle Point in the East, to the Manacles in the West, with the Eddystone in the middle, make up the triangle of my diving area. Whilst each of these areas is famous for its shipwrecks, only the Manacles are truly notorious, and have virtually no redeeming features. It’s sinister and evil reputation is matched only by it’s bleak and forbidding appearance, as it stretches out nearly one and a half miles into the sea, where it lies mostly submerged waiting to entrap the careless or just plain unlucky.

Paris aground with Mohegan's masts in foreground.

Paris aground with Mohegan’s masts in foreground.

Its name derives from the old Cornish words Maen Eglos, meaning church rocks, and a possible reference to the spire of St. Keverne’s church, which has served as a landmark for centuries. More likely it refers to the gravestones that fill the local church yards, because over the centuries more than a hundred ships have been wrecked, drowning well over a thousand people on this unforgiving shore. During one terrible night in 1809, one hundred and ten bodies were washed ashore and many more accounted for, when the transport ship Dispatch, and the Brig, H.M.S. Primrose were dashed to pieces on the Manacles. The emigrant barque John sank in 1855 with the loss of over one hundred and twenty people, and everybody knows about the loss of the liner Mohegan that sailed full speed onto Carn Du rock, drowning one hundred and six poor souls.

The Paris aground on the Manacles.

The Paris aground on the Manacles.

Southeast from Manacle Point is a large red buoy securely held in place with a huge anchor and a heavy chain reaching down nearly two hundred feet to the seabed. Even that and the masts of the sunken liner Mohegan, did not deter the French Liner Paris from running aground in 1899. Luckily she was finally refloated with only the loss of her owners pride, the Andola, four years earlier was not to be so lucky. She was caught in a snowstorm, which reduced visibility to just a few feet. A look out heard the Manacle buoy’s bell tolling in the gloom and the Captain ordered the topsails furled so that he could stand off. It was all too late. The Andola was swept onto the Sharks Fin rock only yards from the Manacles beach.

The wreck of the Andola.

The wreck of the Andola.

z

The list goes on and on. Liners, sailing ships, men of war, coasters and fishing boats, you name it and it has been wrecked on the Manacles. All around, the churchyards have been filled with gravestones, and the lifeboat men from the local villages surrounding this fatal shore have heroically sacrificed their lives to rescue the poor victims.

The Manacles are truly a fatal shore.

Hera

Gull Rock to the east of Falmouth in Veryan Bay, sticks out of the water like the hump of a Sea Dragon. It is so prominent that you would think that it would be easy to avoid. But the sea always lays traps for the unwary, and on the night of 1st of February 1914 Gull rock claimed a victim, the German steel barque Hera.

The Hera.

The Hera.

Originally a British owned vessel called the Richard Wagner, the 1994 ton Hera was owned by Rhederei Aktien of Hamburg, who also owned the ill fated square rigger, Pindos wrecked on the Manacles in 1912. On that February night the Hera was 91 days out of Pisaqua loaded with Chilien nitrates, and closing the Lizard. The weather was rough with a gale blowing, and Captain Lorentz was unsure as to his exact position. He thought to sail slowly into Falmouth bay and pick up the flash of either St. Anthony’s light or the Lizard. As dusk fell the weather steadily worsened and as the hours passed they still saw no shore lights. At about midnight the second mate reported land ahead. Captain Lorentz ordered the Hera put about, but the ship was slow to answer the helm and seconds later the Hera was impaled on Gull Rock about a quarter of a mile off Nare Head.

How the news hit the Headlines.

How the news hit the Headlines.

Distress rockets were fired and lifeboats manned, but the ship suddenly rolled forwards and as she settled by her head, the port boat capsized and Captain Lorentz and three men disappeared. After an attempt to free the starboard boat failed the Chief Officer led the crew up into the rigging to escape the seas that were now sweeping over the boat.

The Hera impaled on the rocks. Photo Paul Thomas.

The Hera impaled on the rocks. Photo Paul Thomas.

As the Hera sank deeper the crew had to climb further up the rigging and soon they were in a dreadful state. Cold and exhaustion soon carried of the Chief Mate and shortly after the Second Mate, Peterson also gave up and slipped into the sea. Before he went he passed over his ships whistle to one of the seamen just above him on the mast.

August Lassen, the boy seaman who blew the whistle.

August Lassen, the boy seaman who blew the whistle.

By this time only five men were left, and they were trapped halfway up the rigging of a sinking ship swept by freezing seas whipped up by a fierce gale. They had to endure these terrible conditions for another two hours before the Falmouth lifeboat finally hove into view. One of the able seamen, his hands so frozen that he could hardly hold the whistle, blew and blew until the lifeboat men heard the shrill sound just barely audible above the howling wind. With the whistle to guide them the cox’n managed to coax the lifeboat alongside the wreck of the Hera and pull the five exhausted crewmen to safety. Nineteen men died that dreadful night and their remains were buried in Veryan churchyard.(see Tombstones sectionHera)

The five survivors.

The five survivors.

 

Today the Hera lies well broken up and scattered on a rock and sandy bottom in about fifty feet of water. It is a very pretty dive with most of the metal spars and plating covered in beautiful plumose anemones. There is plenty here to see and lots of fish life especially large Pollack and a rather large orange coloured starfish.

Wreckage scattered on the beach.  Photo Paul Thomas.

Wreckage scattered on the beach. Photo Paul Thomas.

The highlight for me was part of the upturned hull of the ship. This has formed a sort of iron cave, which you can swim into. Here lurk large Pollack some bass and a small conger. Light filters in from holes in the plating lighting up shoals of small fish and makes the whole experience quite surreal. With winter storms the sand can pile up and almost block the entrances to this cave but usually they are quite clear.

The lifeboat crew to the rescue.

The lifeboat crew to the rescue.

Some of the mast stumps are still to be seen, and although the wreck is well broken up it is still possible to identify what bits you are swimming over. The Hera is a surprisingly compact wreck so there is not much chance of getting lost. But it is very picturesque, so you can stay down a long time, especially if you have a camera.


Listen to this great song about the Hera

Thanks: I am indebted to Ute Lassen for some of these photographs, especially the lad with the whistle who was her Grandfather. I would also like to say how gratefull I am to Paul Thomas for the photographs of the wreck, and the wonderfull story below, of his Great Grandfather William Leuty, who was part of the lifeboat crew.

The Lifeboat Bob Newton with William Leuty circled on the right. Photo Paul Thomas.

The Lifeboat Bob Newton with William Leuty circled on the right. Photo Paul Thomas.

William Leuty was one of the crew of the lifeboat Bob Newton who went to the aid of the stricken Hera. When the lifeboat arrived alongside and found the crew clinging to the masts, Willie Leuty dropped the anchor. As he did so the chain rolled over his hand and severed two fingers. Willie was so cold that he never realised what had happen until he got back home and took of his cloves. Two fingers rolled out. This wasn’t the only shipwreck that William endured. During the First World, William was conscripted into the Devon and Cornwall Light Infantry. In July 1915 he found himself embarked on the steamer Royal Edward en-route to the Dardanelles. On 13th Aug, as the ship was steaming in the Mediterranean, it was torpedoed by the German submarine UB14. Within three minutes the decks were awash, and after six minutes the ship completely sank . Of the 1586 people on board less than 500 were rescued. William Leuty however, survived the dreadful sinking and became something of a hero by helping to cut free one of the lifeboats, so that it fell into the water thus ensuring that many other people were saved. William survived the Great War and became a licensed boatman in Falmouth. I am grateful to Jill Tremarkyn for the information below, and for the wonderful painting of the Hera My grandfather, Ashley Hearle received a message to go to the Nare Head with the rocket life-saving equipment ie breeches bouy to help with the rescue the crew of the Hera on 30th January 1914. This was all done with a team of horses from his farm and men from Gerrans and Portscatho. He told many times how the screams of the dying men haunted him for the rest of his life.

The wreck of the Hera courtesy J. Tremarkyn.

The wreck of the Hera courtesy J. Tremarkyn.

You can see more of the grave, including old photos and a great inscription by clicking the link below.

The hera

German Submarines

One of the strangest wreck incidents occurred in 1921, when a group of six German submarines were wrecked on the rocks along Castle Drive. Originally there were nine submarines allocated to Falmouth under the War Reparations Scheme.These were to be used by the Royal Navy for gunnery practice and certain experiments.

U. Boats at Harwich.

U. Boats at Harwich.

Eight of the submarines finally arrived and were anchored at Gullyngvase. Two were intentionally sunk during the Navy’s experiments, but the remaining six were caught up in a fierce winters gale and swept onto the rocks that stretch along Castle Drive, and abandoned. For many years they were left rusting in the shallows, so close into the shore that it was easy for people to walk out at low tide and board them. They were heavily salvaged and their ownership changed many times. One of the submarines sank very close in near a bathing beach and even today you can still see part of its hull at low tide.

Submarine ashore.

Submarine ashore.

Whilst I am not completely sure that I have all the facts, I think that we have managed to identify four of the submarines. All the subs were launched during 1917. Two of the subs,UB112 and UB106 were built by Bloom and Voss of Hamburg. UB97 was built by Vulcan of Hamburg, and UB86 was built by Wesser of Bremmen. The UB class were about were about 182ft long with a beam of around 12ft. They had two props powered by four stroke diesel engines, which produced 13.5 knots, and two electric motors, which propelled the boat underwater at 7.5 knots. The submarine had a 3.5 inch gun forward of the conning tower and carried ten torpedoes, firing them from four bow tubes and one stern tube. The UB class of submarine had a crew of thirty-seven officers and men.

An example of a UB. class boat.

An example of a UB. class boat.

The subs are heavily covered in weed and well broken up and scattered all along this bit of coast less than a hundred yards offshore. Although I have dived the bit by the bathing beach extensively, (for filming purposes) I have not yet dived on the rest so a proper dive report will follow later. I you have dived on them and want to send me a dive report I would be grateful and put it on the website.

Caroni River

One of the largest wrecks in Falmouth Bay is the Caroni River, a 7807-ton oil tanker. She struck a mine on January 20th 1940, just after she had left the Harbour to carry out engine trials, and she sank with in the hour. This caused a bit of a panic back in Falmouth because the area had recently been swept for conventional mines, and no reports of any aircraft dropping parachute mines had been made. This left only one answer, a German mine laying submarine, which was capable of laying up to nine mines.

Caroni River sinking by the stern.

Caroni River sinking by the stern.

Since the Caroni River had hit one, this left a possible eight mines floating around the busy Bay area. A hasty sweep was made using the Caroni River’s last course and speed as a guide. Sure enough during the next couple of hours eight mines were safely detonated. The Navy at Falmouth however were still very worried. How on earth had the German submarine managed so close inshore at night without running into something? A trip around the Bay that night soon revealed the fact that St. Anthony’s light was well silhouetted against the night sky and it made a very good transit mark with the flashing light of the Manacles buoy. The buoy was quickly extinguished and was not relit until after the War.

The charts of Falmouth Bay show three wrecks right slap in the middle of the Bay. These are in fact all the Caroni River that broke into three pieces as she sank. Today the wreck lies on a bed of sand and shellet in about seventy five feet of water. The visibility is good, usually twenty feet and the wreckage is scattered over a very large area.

I am grateful to James Martin for the 1930 crew list below. His father in law was on the ship at that time.

Crew List.

Crew List.

One of the main surprises was the large numbers of cuckoo wrasse that inhabit this wreck. Here in Plymouth we expect one or two but this seemed like a busman’s holiday. There are large amounts of plating and ribs scattered all about and it is very difficult to decide which bit is which. On the bit I was diving on there was a large section of hull that looked like the bow.

Other than that it is all just a huge jumble of plating and pipes. The fish life is quite good, the usual pouting and small wrasse and there are some small lobsters. Considering the amount of wreckage I would have thought there would be more variety. Generally the Caroni River is a good but uninspiring wreck, even so I feel that I have not seen it at its best so will dive it a few more times to see if my opinion changes.

I am very grateful to Susan Potts-Bury for the following information and photo’s of her Dad.

Dad in Merchant Navy uniform.

Dad in Merchant Navy uniform.

Hi, I am writing up my family tree and I am adding the meat to the bones, so to speak. So seeing your article about the Caroni River is of great interest to me.

Dad with Gran and Grandad on an unidentified ship.

Dad with Gran and Grandad on an unidentified ship.

My Father sailed on the Caroni River for 16 months just before the war. His indenture with Houlder lines of 4 1\2 yrs. (He was on the Elstree Grange first) was up and as he could see war was imminent he decided to join the R.A.F. and be on the winning end of a bomb – he didn’t fancy sitting on an oil tanker while it was being bombed by the enemy.

Dad’s Shipping Apprentice Certificate.

Dad’s Shipping Apprentice Certificate.

In a book about his life he wrote a little about being on the Caroni River. He said that although by today’s standard it was small – to him it looked magnificent. He joined at Falmouth and they sailed to Curacao in the West Indies, Basra and other Gulf Ports picking up oil and transporting it to Europe, Africa and South America. Voyages lasted eight months. My Father finished his indenture in May 1938. Seeing now that the Caroni River ended up being destroyed by a mine – my Father was right to get off ships and join the Air Force.

Dad’s ship demise.

Dad’s ship demise.

Ben Asdale

The Ben Asdale two days after she struck.

The Ben Asdale two days after she struck.

In December 1979 the freezer trawler Ben Asdale was off loading fish in Falmouth Bay in a force eight gale, with heavy snow turning to blizzards. The ship drifted towards Maenporth beach where she ran aground. Two of her crew were lost and the only redeeming feature of that dreadful night was the bravery shown by just about everybody involved. I am extremely lucky to have the Skipper’s first hand account, and the eyewitness account of the Captain of the rescue helicopter, who saved so many lives.

  • The Wreck of the Ben Asdale
  • Commander Mike Norman,Sea King 592
  • Barty Coe – The Skippers Story

The Andromeda

Sometimes you get to dive on a wreck which for some unaccountable reason proves to be irresistible. I say unaccountable, because quite often these wrecks are in shallow water and have little or no real goodies left on them. Even so for some reason or other you find yourself diving on then time and time again. One such wreck is that of the Andromeda, which became wrecked in a southwesterly gale on the 12th February 1915, off Killygerran Head near Portscatho, Cornwall.

The wreck of the Andromeda.

The wreck of the Andromeda.

Built in 1890 by Duncans of Port Glasgow, the Andromeda was a four masted barque of some 1762 registered tons. Commanded by Captain Deeks, the Andromeda had loaded 2500 tons of badly needed grain at Tacoma in Oregon, and had successfully run the gauntlet of enemy submarines when she arrived off Falmouth in the teeth of a blinding south westerly gale. Due to the wartime restrictions in force at the time, Captain Deeks was not allowed to take the Andromeda straight into Falmouth harbour but had to wait for a Pilot. Unfortunately, because of the heavy weather none of the Pilot boats could get out to the Andromeda, who in any event was finding it extremely difficult to weather St Anthony’s Point. At the time Captain Deeks was still very worried about enemy submarines, because the night before when he was off the Scillies the skipper of a merchantman had warned him to keep a good lookout as submarines had recently been seen in that area.

By four o’clock the next morning however, Captain Deeks realised that the submarines were to be the least of his troubles as the gale was rapidly pushing his ship towards the Cornish shore. After ordering the two lifeboats to be made ready, Deeks then dropped both ships anchors. All the crew put on their lifejackets, but unknown to them all, one of their number a seaman called McDonald, was already missing after being washed overboard whilst attending to one of the lifeboats. As the huge seas pounded the Andromeda it became apparent that the anchors were dragging and all on board realised that they were going to hit the rocks. Captain Deeks had his wife and ten year old daughter to worry about as well as his ship and the crew, but because the sea was so ferocious nobody fancied trying to launch the lifeboats. As the Andromeda rushed towards the storm tossed rocks, everybody braced themselves for the shock as she collided. It must have been a heart stopping moment, but happily none of the masts fell down and although a lot of water was washing over the decks the Andromeda did not seem in imminent danger of breaking up.

An apprentice called Reginald Hockeridge started to try and free one of the lifeboats, when first one davit and then the other fell away and he and the boat were flung into the water. The hapless apprentice and the boat were quickly swept onto the rocks where the boat overturned on top of him. He remained trapped in this fashion until another wave lifted the boat from him and he managed to scramble up the rocks to safety.

Meanwhile on board the Andromeda everyone had clambered up the rigging and secured themselves so comfortably that the Captains young daughter promptly fell asleep on the knee of one of the sailors. She obviously had a lot of faith in her Dad and it was not to be misplaced, because at the subsequent inquiry Captain Deeks was praised by all for his competence and efficiency. When the sun finally arose on the following morning the local rocket brigade arrived to effect the crews rescue together with the local Territorials who rigged up a breeches buoy. Everyone was taken off safely, but for the Andromeda the end had come. Later that year stranded and forlorn, she was auctioned for ?70, not much even in those days, and broken up where she lay.

Today her remains lie very close inshore rammed into the large rocks at the bottom of Killygerran Head. The depth of water over the wreck ranges from fifteen to thirty feet, with the wreck lying upright on a sand and rock covered bottom. On a shallow site like this you obviously gets plenty of kelp, but it is not too intrusive and anyway cannot disguise the outline of the wreck. The Andromeda’s ribs and carcass are almost perfectly laid out and it is one of the most picturesque wreck sites that I have ever dived on. The wreckage is strewn over a very large area so there is not much chance of you missing it, and there are some quite large pieces, including some hull ribs, which stick up almost twelve feet.

Close by are what looks like part of a mast leaning on some rocks together with its step (or tabernacle) crammed into a cleft in the rocks almost on the shoreline. The wreck is supposed to be well dived, so much so that I had to persuade some of my companions to go there in the first place. “There’s nothing left” they moaned “too many people go there”. Well the first pair in (not me I am ashamed to say) found a gunmetal deadlight, and another pair found a very nice brass valve but couldn’t get it off, so far as I know it is still there. For the rest of the time you can just browse amongst the wreckage fitting all the bits together in your mind, and look at the beautifully coloured wrasse that wander in and out of the wrecks carcass. Some of the larger pieces of wreckage lie very close inshore jammed into huge rocky reveals. The water can get very turbulent this close in, even on a calm day, and it is easy to get bashed about on the rocks.

Incidentally don’t go wandering off into any of the large caves in this area because quite huge seals inhabit some of them. They might be playful but they don’t seem to like uninvited callers all that much. That day I did three dives on the Andromeda and I wished that it could have been more. Why? Well it is a very good dive, I cannot say more than that, can I.

Small Arms

Many other types of projectile can also be found in large no’s. One of the most common is a 1″ (1lb) lead bullet. This round was fired from a “Sub calibre” aiming rifle tube that was fitted into the breech pieces of larger guns (6″, 9.2″, 15″, etc.) and would allow target shooting without the associated wear and tear on the gun if full calibre rounds were used.

(1lb) aiming tube rounds. These solid lead shot are so common that my weight belt is made from them. It is less common to find a complete round with cartridge case still attached. Possibly ditched overboard as a miss fire. They were still in production well into the 1930's.

(1lb) aiming tube rounds. These solid lead shot are so common that my weight belt is made from them. It is less common to find a complete round with cartridge case still attached. Possibly ditched overboard as a miss fire. They were still in production well into the 1930’s.
These rounds were developed from the earlier

These rounds were developed from the earlier “Nordenfelt machine gun” round. This gun was purchased in large no’s. by the Navy as a means of attacking an enemies deck and gun crews and also as an anti torpedo boat gun.
The machine gun round was a tubular

The machine gun round was a tubular “Brass envelope” containing a cast iron penetrator core. The brass would take the rifling and the cast iron body would penetrate up to about 2″ armour plating at approx. 300yds. range.
The gun was a contemporary of the better known American Gatling gun but did not suffer to anything like the extent that it did with jamming and round separation problems.

The gun was a contemporary of the better known American Gatling gun but did not suffer to anything like the extent that it did with jamming and round separation problems.
Nordenfelt rounds. More likely to be found like the bottom one, with cast iron core rotted away by seawater.

Nordenfelt rounds. More likely to be found like the bottom one, with cast iron core rotted away by seawater.
Cast iron core rotted away by seawater.

Cast iron core rotted away by seawater.

Many other rounds have been fired into the sea over the years and a selection of finds are shown below:-

20mm. Oerlikon. Fired from HMS Cambridge shore training base.

20mm. Oerlikon. Fired from HMS Cambridge shore training base.

 

0.50

0.50″ cal. Browning Machine gun round. This round is still in use in several guises, most notably the “Barratt” & AWF 50 sniper rifles, and, in IRA hands, has been responsible for the deaths of many soldiers serving in Northern Ireland
303; Lee Enfield bullets

303; Lee Enfield bullets
5.56mm. (0.22

5.56mm. (0.22″). The new Nato standard.
7.62mm. Self loading Rifle round. This used to be the old Nato standard.

7.62mm. Self loading Rifle round. This used to be the old Nato standard.
0.45 Martini Henry.

0.45 Martini Henry.


Extract from Bombs and Bullets DVD

Cannonballs

It is inevitable that Divers will find many types of “Artillery projectiles” and other types of ordnance when diving arround Plymouth. Over the centuries large numbers were fired out into the sea from the numerous shore batteries that line the edges of the Sound. Finds from the earliest times are typically “Roundshot” ( cannonballs) and mainly were fired from Staddon Point Battery and the early Picklecombe Fort.

Cleaned up solid round shot. Probably a 12lb and 32lb. Shot were measured by weight as a sphere will always contain the same amount of metal for a given diameter. A 32lb shot was approx 6.25

Cleaned up solid round shot. Probably a 12lb and 32lb. Shot were measured by weight as a sphere will always contain the same amount of metal for a given diameter. A 32lb shot was approx 6.25″ in diameter.

The guns had ranges out to about 2,000 yards and if an arc is drawn on a map of the Sound it will show where most shot are to be found.

Map showing Ranges.

Map showing Ranges.

These two forts below are the source of many of the “Cannonballs” that are found in the waters off Plymouth.

Picklecombe Fort circa 1849.

Picklecombe Fort circa 1849.
Staddon Fort and Bovisand Battery.

Staddon Fort and Bovisand Battery.

Due to chemical reaction with seawater, a “Concretion” up to about 2″ thick will form on “Cast Iron” objects and the carbon content of the metal itself gradually converts to a form of graphite. This will fall to dust if the projectile / cannonball is raised and dried out.

Roundshot found on seabed at low

Roundshot found on seabed at low “Spring tide” offshore from an old Gunnery range. Newer RML projectiles can be seen in background.

Sometimes you can find two small cannon balls joined by a metal bar. These are called Bar Shot and were very usefull in ripping sails, or chopping down masts. You can also find them joined with chain but these are very rare as the chain tends to rust away.

 

Bar Shot.

Bar Shot.

You can also find cannonballs with a wooden peg in them. These are full of ‘black powder’ and the wooden peg acted as a crude fuse.These were more properly called a ‘mortar’ and were fired at a ship or land battery, and exploded when it hit the side of the ship or fort.They were not very effective but there are quite a few to be found in shallow water. If dried out the ‘black powder’ will probably ignite, so its not one for putting by your fireplace.

The Brennan Torpedo

The Brennan torpedo, invented around 1876, was the very first wire guided torpedo, and was similar in appearance to the modern day type, save that instead of being circular in cross-section it was fish shaped. It was designed to run to run at a consistent depth of twelve feet underwater and had an indicator mast sticking up from the torpedo until it just broke the surface. At night this mast had a small light fitted which was only visible from the rear.

The only example of the Brennan Torpedo is on show at Chatham Dockyard.

The only example of the Brennan Torpedo is on show at Chatham Dockyard.

In the body of the torpedo, two steel drums were mounted, each carrying several miles of high tensile steel wire. The drums were connected through a differential gear to the twin in line propellers arranged to rotate in opposite directions. If one drum were rotated faster than the other then, although the propellers rotated at the same speed, the rudder was activated. The twin wires from the drums passed out through the tail shaft, small steel rings embracing the wires were paid out at intervals thus preventing the wires from separating. The other ends of the wires were connected to winding engines, either on a ship or (mostly) land base, and these twin winding gears were so arranged that their respective speeds could be varied within fine limits, thus providing sensitive control for steering the torpedo towards its target.

Various cross sections of the torpedo showing the workings.

Various cross sections of the torpedo showing the workings.
Various cross sections of the torpedo showing the workings.

Various cross sections of the torpedo showing the workings.
Various cross sections of the torpedo showing the workings.

Various cross sections of the torpedo showing the workings.
Various cross sections of the torpedo showing the workings.

Various cross sections of the torpedo showing the workings.

The torpedo attained a speed of 20 knots using a wire .04 inches in diameter but later this was changed to .07 inches to increase the speed to 27 knots. The torpedo was fitted with leading elevators controlled by a depth mechanism and with the fore and aft rudders operated by the differential between the drums. The method of operation was that the officer in charge would be either in an elevated position in the ship or, if on a land base, on a 40ft high telescopic steel tower, hydraulically extended. He was provided with a pair of binoculars on which was a keyboard from which he could control electrically the relative speeds of the twin winding engines. In this manner he was able to follow the track of the torpedo and steer it with a great degree of accuracy. In tests carried out by the Admiralty the operator was able to hit a floating fruit basket at 2000 yards and demonstrated the ability of the torpedo to turn through 180 degrees and so attack a ship from the off side.

Diagram of Torpedo.

Diagram of Torpedo.

The Admiralty, at first enthusiastic then took against the weapon and in 1884 told Brennan that they had no use ‘for a new way of destroying shipping’ However a few weeks later Brennan received a letter from the War Office stating that they had decided to adopt his torpedo as a means of harbour defence and he was invited to attend a meeting to place a value on his invention. Brennan, considerably out of pocket decided to accept ?40,000 as a quick fix to his financial worries but his able business partner J.R.Temperly took over the negotiations and demanded ?100,000.The War Office agreed to this, but said they would have to pay it over three years. Brennan accepted this, but Temperly demanded another ?10,000 for the delay and after a bit of wrangling the War Office agreed. Brennan was delighted and every year he would drive to the bank of England in a horse and cart and collect the equivalent of his fee in gold bars. The Brennan torpedo became standard harbour defence throughout the British Empire and was in use for more than fifteen years.

Louis Brennan:

Born in Castlebar, County Mayo in 1852, Brennan was still a small child when his family emigrated to Australia, where in due course he attended the College for Artisans in Melbourne.

Louis Brennan:

Louis Brennan:

Besides the torpedo he invented a gyroscopic monorail and a type of helicopter. In spite of his inventive genius and a charming personality his private life was tragic. He lost one of his two daughters in the flu epidemic that followed the First World War, his wife was mentally unbalanced, and his son had to give up a promising Army career for the same reason and died at an early age in an institution. Brennan was knocked down by a car in Switzerland in December 1931 and died a month later on 17th January 1932; he was 79 years of age.

Pier Cellars:

Pier Cellars dates from around 1560 when it was used for the storage and smoking of Pilchards. The small buildings above the Harbour have been used as a farmhouse, a grog shop and the local headquarters for the later detachments stationed there in the 1900’s. The cellars were requisitioned by the government in 1889 to house the newly developed Brennan torpedo. Each station had twelve torpedos and was manned by one officer, one mechanist, eight N.C.O.s and two engine drivers. The pier that was adjacent was used to land stores and munitions for the station.

Plan of Pier Cellars.

Plan of Pier Cellars.

The original engines were steam driven, and after the torpedos were taken out of service search lights were installed which were driven by a generator belonging to Hancocks the fairground owners. Three guns were installed in 1898 to the left of the house. These were a 12 pounder and two QF anti aircraft guns. Two searchlights were used to provide crossbeams to range the guns at night. The station was ‘tested’ in 1901 and 1902 when the lights were operated by a detachment of the Royal Engineers and the guns were manned by the 2nd Devon Volunteer Artillery.

Pier Cellars showing the sloping ramp used to launch the Torpedo.

Pier Cellars showing the sloping ramp used to launch the Torpedo.

The station was closed in 1906 as the policy changed from static torpedo bases to the torpedo boat destroyer. The stores and equipment were either returned to Chatham or scrapped on site. Although the station was all but closed the guns still remained. The pier was removed in 1914 as a precaution against the enemy using it as a landing place and the guns were finally taken away in 1920. During World War two the station was used for the development and testing of one and two man torpedos of the Welman Chariot type. Pier Cellars is currently used by the navy as an assault course and training base.

Brennan Torpedo: The History and…

This excellent book will tell you all you could wish to know about the torpedo.

Breach and Muzzle Loaders

In 1859 the French launched “La Gloire”. This armoured warship was developed using knowledge gained during the “Crimean War” when it was found that “Roundshot” fired from smoothbore cannon would bounce off the sides of “Armoured Ships” and cause no damage. Her appearance rendered all of our coastal defence forts, and our wooden walled warships, obsolete overnight.

La Gloire.

La Gloire.

This sparked an arms race the like of which had never been seen before, and whose effect is carried on to this day. Although explosive shells had been available for smoothbore cannon for many years, they were still spherical and had minimal penetrative effect. A pointed, cylindrical projectile was required, along with a much higher velocity when fired.

Armstrong

Armstrong” lead coated shell showing rifling marks engraved into lead from firing.

The earliest, successful guns and projectiles that fitted this bill were those produced by Sir Thomas Armstrong in the 1860’s. The guns were “Rifled” and the projectiles were lead coated to allow the rifling to grip and rotate the shell thus giving it greater accuracy and range. The lead coating also sealed the gap between the shell and the bore thus minimising the amount of “Windage” or “Blowpast” of gases and ensuring that more of the energy from the gunpowder’s explosion went into driving the projectile.

Replica

Replica “Armstrong” Breech loading gun at Crownhil fort showing the weakness inherent in its design with gases escaping from beneath the breech.

Also, because it was now cylindrical, much greater weight of impact could be concentrated on its target than was possible with spherical shot. There was a drawback with “Armstrong” guns, however, in that the metal technology of the day was not quite up to the mark, and there were many instances of the breeches of these guns blowing out and killing and maiming the gun crew. Also the lead coating was prone to stripping off on firing and the shell would become unbalanced and fly off in unpredictable directions.

“Armstrong” lead coated solid shot.

By the mid 1860’s guns reverted to being muzzle loaded. This was not the apparent retrograde step it first appeared. Gun manufacturing and casting techniques were better understood and weapons up to 17.25″ calibre could be made. Those around Plymouth ranged from a fairly small 2.5″ (7 & 9lb.) field gun up to 12″ or 13.5″ pieces. Most common size found is the 6″ (64lb) shell, but 9″ & 12″ are frequently seen as well.

6

6″ (64lb) RML shells

These guns were rifled with 3 or 5 or more coarse grooves, the shells carried a series of Copper / Bronze studs which rode in the grooves to impart rotation to the shell on firing.

7 & 9lb field gun RML shells

7 & 9lb field gun RML shells

Because the shell had to be a fairly loose fit in the guns bore to allow it to be loaded, a large copper disc was first placed on top of the powder charge before the shell was loaded.

Two types of Gas Check. The right hand one is, unusually, intact.

Two types of Gas Check. The right hand one is, unusually, intact.

This “Obturator” or “Gas check” would be forced onto sharp radial ribs on the rear of the shell on firing and through this grip would spin the shell to stabilise it in flight. These can sometimes be found but are usually badly damaged.

!2 inch R.M.L. on Drakes Island, Plymouth.

!2 inch R.M.L. on Drakes Island, Plymouth.

Largest RML ever produced were the 17.25″ (100 ton) weapons that were emplaced on Malta and Gibraltar. Only example now existing is on Malta at Fort Rinella.

17.25

17.25″ (100 ton) RML Gun and Emplacement.

RML Guns continued in use until approx. 1895-1900. Many old and obsolete smooth bore cannon given a new lease of life by having a “Rifled liner” inserted and expanded into place by firing a heavy “proof” charge. These were called “Palliser Conversions” an example of which can be seen at Dartmouth.

17.25

17.25″ (100 ton) RML shell.

By 1890’s technology allowed newer and better Breech Loading Guns to be manufactured. The shells for these guns were also fairly different in that instead of studs ( and the weakness they built into the shell body) they were fitted with a circular “Driving band” an inch or more up from the base of the shell. This again provided a gas seal and also provided the means to spin the shell in its passage up the guns barrel.

6

6″ breech loaded shot on seabed showing “Driving Band” and thickness of “Concretion” which has been partially removed.
6

6″ breech loaded shot on seabed showing “Driving Band” and thickness of “Concretion” which has been partially removed.

Base and Nose Fuses

The “Base Fuse, Impact” as shown below, was fitted into the base of a shell’s projectile. This served a two fold purpose,

A complete

A complete “Base Fuse”

1) to ensure a level of “Bore Safety” and prevent the shell exploding prior to being fired, and,

A firing pin in its unset position before the shell has been fired.

A firing pin in its unset position before the shell has been fired.

2) to ensure that, once fired, the shell would explode upon hitting something. This was arranged by having a firing pin in the base fuse set into a piece of soft metal in such a way that it was impossible for it to set off the main charge.

A firing pin as would be found once the shell has been fired and is now in a condition ready to set off the projectile on impact.

A firing pin as would be found once the shell has been fired and is now in a condition ready to set off the projectile on impact.

Once the round had been fired inertia would force the soft metal to the rear of the pin and expose the sharp tip. Now if an object was struck the pin would fly forward and the point would set off the shells explosive charge.

Base fuses

Base fuses” were frequently replaced by solid plugs when the shell was fired.

“Base fuses” were frequently replaced by solid plugs when the shell was fired for training purposes, the shell was then filled with an inert substance that would replicate the “Live” rounds weight and so unaffect its ballistic characteristics. There many other types of “Base impact fuses” and were mainly fitted into the larger types of shellThey could also be fitted with a delay feature that would ensure that the shell would explode once it had passed through an object and its fragments, as well as the explosion itself, would damage material and men behind whatever it had penetrated.

These larger

These larger “Base Impact fuses” were sometimes fitted with a time delay feature and were also replaced with solid plugs for training purposes.

As armour plate became more effective a new type of shell evolved and this was the “Palliser chilled tip armour piercing shell”. As its name suggests it had a tip that was formed in a special mold that would ensure it was rapidly cooled when being cast. This resulted in an extremely hard metal that could penetrate any armour plate then existing. It wasn’t until WW11, and the introduction of much superior armour plate, that these shot were defeated. A shell utilizing a shaped charge warhead that depended upon the “Monroe effect” had to be developed to defeat these newer armours, and even now in 2002 the contest between “Armour” and “Shell” continues unabated. Modern armours consist mainly of “Composites”, meaning layers of differing materials, and even “Reactive” materials that will explode on being hit and thus dissipate the energy of the impacting shot or shell.

An early Nose Fuse that would have been fitted to the relatively slow moving RML. Shells.

An early Nose Fuse that would have been fitted to the relatively slow moving RML. Shells.

Nose mounted fuses were also developed in many guises and these enabled a shell to be exploded in the air, after a set amount of time had elapsed, before it had hit anything. This found its greatest use in WW1 when it was used to explode “Shrapnell Shells” above and in front of an advancing enemy. It did this to such effect that many, many more men were killed by artillery fired “Shrapnell shells” than from any other cause.

A later style of Nose fuse fitted to larger shells and able to give a longer delay and so a greater range before detonation.

A later style of Nose fuse fitted to larger shells and able to give a longer delay and so a greater range before detonation.


Extract from Bombs and Bullets DVD

Below is a drawing showing the type of shell to which the above fuse would have been fitted. After firing, the time set on the fuse would expire, and the fuse would fire down the shells central tube to ignite the powder charge contained in its base behind the charge of balls. This powder would then explode and force the balls forward along the shells line of flight like some huge shotgun blast. Its killing power over a large area was tremendous, and it replaced the much earlier “Case” and “Canister” shells as the prime “Man-killing” weapon on the battlefield.

Shrapnell Diagram.

Shrapnell Diagram.

There are many other applications for delayed action fuses, chief amongst them being in an Anti- Aircraft role, and because of WW11, there are many thousands of fuses from successfully exploded shells, and also complete un-exploded rounds where the fuse failed, laying on the sea bed waiting to be found.. Once the round had been fired, the time delay set on the fuse should have ensured that the shell exploded at the end of its flight, however, this didn’t always happen and so an impact element was built into the fuse to ensure it exploded on hitting the ground or the sea, again this didn’t always occur, so there are many shells on the sea bed that have not exploded correctly. This was ok if the gun was firing out over the sea, but caused problems if being fired over land, as the population then not only had to contend with falling bombs but also with faulty AAA shells. Where small weapons were involved such as the 2pdr. Pom Pom or the 40mm. Bofors this wasn’t too much of a problem, but if you had some 3.7″ or even larger 6″ shells coming down then it could ruin your whole day quite abruptly.

The battery section of this fuse would have been on the end to the right and has long since rotted away. There may, however, be an electric primer and detonator still in the fuse body, and although unlikely, it may still be

The battery section of this fuse would have been on the end to the right and has long since rotted away. There may, however, be an electric primer and detonator still in the fuse body, and although unlikely, it may still be “Live”. If uncertainty exists then leave it alone.

As technology improved it became possible to fit a form of Radar into a shell fuse and this could be set so as to detonate the shell when the reflected return from the target ensured that it was close enough to be destroyed by the exploding shell. These “Proximity shells” were a saviour for the South East of England during WW11 when the Germans started sending over large no.s. of V1’s.. The fuses ensured that the AAA batteries were able to shoot the majority down before they reached any major population centres.

Radar transparent

Radar transparent “Ballistic cap” removed.

The fuse depended upon the shock of firing breaking a capsule of electrolyte, and the spin of the shells rotation rapidly spread this over the cells of a battery. After a short time the battery was powered up and would energize a small built in Radar emitter.

Electronics etc. encapsulated in Nylon / Plastic.

Electronics etc. encapsulated in Nylon / Plastic.

This would then transmit its signal through the Radar transparent plastic nose cone of the fuse, and , when it received a strong enough return signal, it would detonate the shell . These fuses can also be found on the sea bed from the rounds fired by HMS Cambridge during AAA training for the Navy. Because of the materials used in their construction they rapidly rot away and are seldom worth recovering.

Diagram of electric fuse.

Diagram of electric fuse.

 

Black Powder and Cordite

Other finds are mainly rounds that have been dumped due to either misfire or being surplus issue at the end of a ships commission.Some of these are empty but can still have percussion fuses in their base, and others are usually still full of propellant.

Percussion fuse on the base of a 2 pdr.

Percussion fuse on the base of a 2 pdr.

Either way great care is required with these rounds as even after what could be 100 years underwater, the propellant will still burn fiercely if ignited,and the fuses can still explode. Even Blackpowder will burn if the sealing on the cartridge was in good condition.

80 year old 4

80 year old 4″ round as found on sea bed filled with cordite.
80 year old 4

80 year old 4″ round as found on sea bed filled with cordite.
2 sticks from same round showing it will still readily burn.

2 sticks from same round showing it will still readily burn.

Below is a Nordenfelt 3 pdr. Cartridge case showing a base mounted fuse still in the mouth of the case along with the remains of a projectile long since rotted away. This case is full of “Black powder” propellant which will possibly still burn if allowed to dry out.

Below is a cleaned up Nordenfelt 3 pdr.

Below is a cleaned up Nordenfelt 3 pdr.
Below is a cleaned up Nordenfelt 3 pdr.

Below is a cleaned up Nordenfelt 3 pdr.
Above is a cleaned up version of a 105 mm cartridge case which still can be found on various wrecks or just lying on the sea bed.

Above is a cleaned up version of a 105 mm cartridge case which still can be found on various wrecks or just lying on the sea bed.

Anti Aircraft Artillery

Other common finds are numerous types of Anti-aircraft artillery (AAA) shells. The older ones are from a derivation of the 1880’s pattern “Maxim” automatic machine gun and were called the 2 pdr. Pom Pom. These guns were fitted to warships up to and during WW2 by which time they were obsolete.

Pom Pom Gun

Pom Pom Gun

They were superseded by the much more effective 40mm. L40/60 Bofors Gun. Other, newer, larger sized AAA can be found, but as the self destruct fuse has obviously not operated then they are, again, best left alone.

2 pdr. pom pom round

2 pdr. pom pom round

 

Comparison between 40mm. Bofors (top) and 2 pdr.Pom Pom (bottom).

Comparison between 40mm. Bofors (top) and 2 pdr.Pom Pom (bottom).

2 Pdr Pom Pom suffered from frequent jamming problems and it became the norm to issue a large mallet with each mounting in order to give the offending breech a “Seamanlike” whack to free the guns mechanism up again.

A concreted mass of 2pdr. shells from a wreck near the Poulmic.

A concreted mass of 2pdr. shells from a wreck near the Poulmic.

Some of the wrecks around Plymouth used to have huge quanties of 2pdr. shells, but most have now been cleared away. Even so it is not unusual to still find one.

The same shells chipped out.

The same shells chipped out.
The shells still have plenty of cordite in them so beware.

The shells still have plenty of cordite in them so beware.
  • Your Custom Previous Link Text
  • 1
  • 2

Submerged Books and DVDs

The Wreckers Guide To South West Devon Part 1
The Wrecker's Guide To South West Devon Part 1
The Wreckers Guide To South West Devon Part 2
The Wrecker's Guide To South West Devon Part 2
Plymouth Breakwater Book
The Plymouth Breakwater Book
The Plymouth Breakwater DVD
The Plymouth Breakwater DVD
Shooting Magic DVD
Shooting Magic DVD
Devon Shipwrecks DVD
Devon Shipwrecks DVD
The Silent Menace DVD
The Silent Menace DVD
The Tragedy Of The HMS Dasher DVD
The Tragedy Of the The HMS Dasher DVD
Missing  DVD
Missing: The Story Of The A7 Submarine DVD
HMS Royal Oak DVD
HMS Royal Oak DVD
Bombs And Bullets DVD
Bombs And Bullets DVD
Bay Watch DVD
Bay Watch DVD

Search Submerged

Devon Shipwrecks

  • Blesk
  • Bolt Head To Bolt Tail
  • Cantabria
  • HMS Coronation and the Penlee Cannons
  • Deventure
  • Dimitrios
  • Elk
  • Empire Harry
  • HMS Foyle
  • Fylrix
  • Glen Strathallen
  • Halloween
  • Herzogin Cecillie
  • Hiogo
  • James Egan Layne
  • Jebba
  • Liberta
  • Louis Shied
  • Maine
  • Medoc
  • Nepaul
  • Oregon
  • Persier
  • Plymouth Breakwater
  • Poulmic
  • Prawle Point
  • Ramillies
  • Riversdale
  • Rosehill
  • Skaalla
  • Soudan
  • Sunderland
  • Flying Boats
  • Scylla
  • Totnes Castle
  • Vectis
  • Viking Princess
  • Yvonne

World Shipwrecks

  • Narvik
  • Scilly Isles
  • Scapa Flow
  • Truk Lagoon
  • Falmouth
  • Other World Wrecks
  • South Africa
  • Tombstones
  • Submarines
  • The Ones That Got Away
  • Bombs And Bullets
  • Marine Archeology
  • Wreck Walks

Shipwreck Book Reviews

  • Neutral Buoyancy – Tim Ecott
  • Admiral Shovell’s Treasure-R.Larn & R.McBride
  • The Silent Service – John Parker
  • Scapa Flow In War And Peace-W.S.Hewison
  • This Great Harbour-W.S.Hewison
  • The Duchess-Pamela Eriksson
  • Stokers Submarine-Fred &Liz Brencley
  • The Wreck at Sharpnose Point – J.Seale
  • Business in Great Waters – John Terraine
  • Submarine in Camera – Hall & Kemp
  • Autumn of the Uboats – Geoff Jones
  • Under the Red Sea – Hans Hass
  • To Unplumbed Depths – Hans Hass
  • Goldfinger – Keith Jessop
  • Custom of the Sea – Niel Hanson
  • Stalin’s Gold – Barry Penrose
  • Pieces of Eight – Kip Wagner
  • The Man Who Bought a Navy – Gerald Bowman
  • The Treasure Divers – Kendall McDonald
  • The Deepest Days – Robert Stenhuit
  • The Wreck Hunters – Kendal McDonald
  • Sea Diver – Marion Clayton Link
  • The Other Titanic – Simon Martin
  • Falco,chief diver of the Calypso – Falco & Diole
  • World without Sun – J.Y.Cousteau
  • Ship of Gold – Gary Kinder
  • Seven Miles Down – Piccard & Dietz
  • The Living Sea – J.Y.Cousteau
  • The Undersea Adventure – Philip Diole
  • Life and Death in a Coral Sea – J.Y.Cousteau
  • Dolphins – J.Y.Cousteau
  • Whale – J.Y.Cousteau
  • Shark – J.Y.Cousteau
  • Sea Lion- Elephant Seal and Walrus – J.Y.Cousteau
  • Octopus and Squid – J.Y.Cousteau
  • Shadow Divers – Robert Kurson
  • A Time to Die, the story of the Kursk – R. Moore
  • The Sea Around Us – Rachel Carson

© 1999–2025 Peter Mitchell and Chris Mitchell. All rights reserved.